Unyielding Watchdog Pursuits Highlight Fourth-Quarter Awards of Excellence
The fourth-quarter Awards of Excellence wrap up a strong year in watchdog journalism, in-depth reporting and a commitment to serving our communities through new tools and platforms. Gannett journalists are poised to maintain this innovative momentum in 2013.
Superstorm Sandy was the biggest news story of the quarter. This storm affected sites in the Northeast, wreaking havoc along the coastline. The Asbury Park Press, Poughkeepsie Journal and The Journal News at Westchester, along with many other sites, kept their communities informed with real-time social media and mobile reporting. The Press retooled its website and mobile platforms to become a hub of hurricane resources focused on keeping citizens safe.
The Poughkeepsie Journal made great use of LiveStream to broadcast weather conditions, traffic problems and update areas hit hardest by the storm. The Home News Tribune of East Brunswick did not back down from Sandy’s challenge. Their in-depth coverage of power outages focused on the real voices of the community.
The Detroit Free Press and Montgomery Advertiser both impressed judges with their dogged watchdog efforts. The Freep’s “truth-squadding” exposed a billionaire’s effort to buy a ballot initiative and stop a proposed bridge between the United States and Canada. The Advertiser’s investigation into schools changing student grades in order to meet federal standards ended with seven district employees being suspended.
The fourth-quarter entries were filled with powerful writing and storytelling. Springfield News-Leader reporter Claudette Riley’s narrative about the heartbreaking life and death of a 14-year-old boy was “impossible to stop reading.” Mark Caudill’s reporting of a woman kidnapped at gunpoint made News Journal readers in Mansfield, Ohio, feel this woman’s fear and courage.
Top performing sites were:
– Division I: Des Moines (6), Asbury Park (5)
– Division II: Poughkeepsie (7), Springfield (4)
– Division III: East Brunswick (5), Lafayette LA (4)
– Design Studios: Asbury Park (5), Des Moines (4)
Judges
Judges for the fourth quarter were: Felecia Wellington, online copy editor, Asbury Park Press; Karen Magnuson, vice president/news and editor, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle; Jennifer Herrmann, design team leader, Design Studio at The Courier-Journal at Louisville; Kristin Askelson, managing editor, The Daily Advertiser at Lafayette, La.; David Stoeffler, executive editor, Springfield News-Leader and Glenn Judah, digital editor, The Spectrum at St. George.
Watchdog Journalism
Division I
First Place
Detroit Free Press
John Gallagher, staff writer; Paul Egan, Detroit Free Press Lansing Bureau; Stephen Henderson, Detroit editorial page editor
For a series of awesome truth-squadding stories, explanatory reporting and opinion pieces exposing the distortions and lies of an aggressive campaign launched by a businessman to derail a proposed bridge between the United States and Canada.
Judges said: “Detroit’s work is truth-squadding at its best. After Michigan, the United States and Canada agreed to build a second bridge from Detroit to Canada, the billionaire owner of the existing (private) Ambassador Bridge invested more than $30 million for an ad and telemarketing campaign that he hoped would put a stop to it. Matty Moroun’s ads slammed the bridge proposal and pushed passage of a state ballot initiative he had developed to block the new bridge. The Free Press smartly 
tapped independent experts in advertising ethics and international law who analyzed – and debunked – Moroun’s claims. The Free Press was the only media outlet to report the comprehensive truth. The Freep also exposed a sleazy telemarketing effort by obtaining a copy of the script, created to sow confusion, and reacted immediately with truth-squad coverage when glossy flyers hit voters’ mailboxes the Saturday before Election Day. Thanks at least in part to the Free Press, the voters didn’t buy the information in the ads, and Mouron’s ballot proposal failed. Real democracy at work in Detroit!”
Finalists
The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Dennis Wagner, senior reporter
For a three-part series, “Letting Down The Guard,” that uncovered a shocking pattern of criminal and unethical conduct in the Arizona National Guard and suggested strategies for reform.
Judges said: “The investigation began when the Republic received a tip from a lieutenant colonel who wanted to talk about corruption and failed leadership in the Arizona National Guard. Senior reporter Dennis Wagner went to work, interviewing Guard officers, soldiers and airmen and filing more than a dozen state and federal public records requests to obtain military investigations, police reports, inspector general files and documents from the governor’s office. His reporting in the three-day series “Letting Down The Guard” does a superb job of documenting and explaining the culture of shocking criminal and ethical conduct while suggesting strategies for reform. The reports prompted Gov. Jan Brewer to bring in a two-star general to conduct an investigation that will no doubt lead to change in National Guard operations.”
The Des Moines Register
Kyle Munson, reporter; Jeffrey Kummer, editor
For a special report by Register reporter Kyle Munson and his editor, Jeffrey Kummer, on what is driving bullying in Iowa schools and the failure of some schools – and state officials overall – to properly track it.
Judges said: “The Register’s eye-opening analysis of more than 67,000 reports filed with the state shed light on the most common form of bullying – physical violence – and exposed schools that failed to report any instances of bullying as required by the state. The coverage also held the state accountable for failing to analyze the data and follow up with schools that did not file reports.”
The Courier-Journal at Louisville
Jason Riley and Andrew Wolfson, reporters
For an investigation by reporters Jason Riley and Andrew Wolfson of judges – and three in particular – who regularly acquitted accused drunk drivers for flimsy reasons.
Judges said: “The reporters looked at every case for five years in which DUI defendants requested a trial before a judge rather than a jury – more than 200 cases in all. They reviewed hundreds of pages of court records and viewed dozens of trial videos in their entirety. In nearly three-quarters of the cases, the defendant went free, and many were exonerated for the flimsiest of reasons. The video accompanying the package made great use of trial video and other visuals to bring the story to life on digital platforms.”
Division II
First Place
Montgomery Advertiser
Josh Moon, enterprise reporter
For The Montgomery Advertiser’s work to uncover a systematic program to change the grades of students to help make it appear public high schools were meeting federal standards. The Advertiser’s reporting forced the hand of the district, which announced its own investigation of “rumors” knowing of the pending publication of the story. The report found that teachers were pressured to make changes because the district was struggling to meet annual goals under the federal No Child Left Behind Act. Subsequent investigations by the Montgomery Public Schools and the state of Alabama led to the suspension of seven district employees.
Judges said: “This was classic watchdog work by reporter Josh Moon, who during more than four months of work interviewed more than 40 current and former school employees, many of whom agreed to speak on the record – and even on camera
– about the system of changing grades. Moon obtained documentary evidence – including emails and recordings of conversations with teachers talking casually about changing grades.”
Finalists
Poughkeepsie Journal
Mary Beth Pfeiffer, projects writer
For The Journal’s seminal work on Lyme disease and its repercussions in the Hudson Valley, a region with the nation’s highest rates for the disease. In this series, reporter Mary Beth Pfeiffer produced an authoritative report on Lyme disease testing and diagnosis. She found that the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention may be overstating the ease and efficiency of Lyme testing.
Judges said: “Mary Beth Pfeiffer dove deep into the complex world of medical and scientific literature, piecing together a readable package that challenged the most basic claim of the CDC – that Lyme sufferers will ‘almost always test positive.’ Her dogged work showed it was not always such a simple fact.”
Wausau Daily Herald
Amanda Seitz, reporter
For reporter Amanda Seitz’s update on a stalled local highway project and expose on how the city’s mishandling of the project had prompted a previously undisclosed federal investigation – and a subsequent ban on federal funding for that project and limits on other projects.
Judges said: “Good source work yielded great results for reporter Amanda Seitz, who exposed a cover-up at city hall, where the mayor and public works director knew about a federal investigation into a local highway project – but had not shared that information with members of the city council or with residents whose lives have been disrupted waiting for a highway project to move forward.”
Great Falls Tribune
Karl Puckett, reporter
For turning a routine state purchase of land into a public outcry after the Great Falls Tribune began to look into the value of the purchase and why it was given a higher priority for conservation than other possible properties. “Is this land worth $6.1 million?” was the question on the lead story in the series, which prompted wildlife organizations and landowners to ask the state to delay the purchase. When the state refused, other landowners closed their property to public hunting in protest.
Judges said: “Reporter Karl Puckett dug into market appraisals and the state’s own rankings of wildlife value, plus conducted extensive interviews to present a balanced report that raised key questions about the process used to purchase this piece of land. His reporting led to strong public reaction.”
Division III
First Place
Iowa City Press-Citizen
Josh O’Leary and Tara Bannow, reporters
For coverage
that revealed sexual harassment at the University of Iowa and the intention of the school president to keep that information from the public.
Judges said: “The Press-Citizen’s thorough reporting holds a publicly funded university accountable for its actions on several levels. The initial report reveals the inappropriate and criminal behavior of a senior adviser. By itself, a story that merits recognition. What comes next is something journalists everywhere are fighting. The university president admits on the record that she would have kept the sexual harassment a secret, calling it a ‘personnel’ matter. The coverage was impactful, and the resulting policy changes will increase transparency and accountability at a public institution.”
Finalists
The Leaf-Chronicle at Clarksville
Lester Black, city government reporter
For a single story that revealed funding sources of a PAC inserting itself into a city council race.
Judges said: “In a classic example of small-town politics run amok, Lester Black’s diligent reporting revealed a mayor trying to hide behind a PAC that was attacking her opponents on city council. Campaign finance reports revealed the PAC was funded by the mayor’s mother, her campaign treasurer and two vocal supporters. In addition, some of the PAC’s allegations were unfounded, which Black makes clear to readers. His reporting is thorough and well-sourced and he explains the issues clearly for readers.”
Pacific Daily News at Guam
Staff
For a series of watchdog stories linking police officers to a brothel engaged in forced prostitution.
Judges said: “Kudos to the Pacific Daily News for its tenacious reporting on this issue. Despite the fact that the brothel was shut down and its owner sent to prison for life, they continued to put pressure on the police department to investigate allegations against officers. The PDN does an excellent job of using court records to tell a compelling story of abuse and corruption. Their work has resulted in recognition from civic leaders and a reopening of the investigation.”
The Daily Journal at Vineland
Deborah M. Marko, reporter, Jason Alt, managing editor
For a single watchdog report on a public official discovered using his work computer to surf porn and the collusion of other officials to keep it a secret.
Judges said: “We know some of the best watchdog stories are the result of good, solid beat reporting, and this is a perfect example of that. Following up on a source’s tip, reporter Deborah Marko was able document this incredible case of malfeasance and cover up. She builds a case with public records and does an excellent job of explaining to readers what went wrong. Managing editor Jason Alt’s editorial added even more accountability to the coverage.”
Public Service Journalism
Division I
First Place
Asbury Park Press
Staff
For outstanding public service journalism throughout Superstorm Sandy. During the Jersey Shore’s darkest days, the Asbury Park Press was at its brightest. When people needed help, the Press, APP.com and its social media efforts were there, providing “real-time public service” that went beyond the expected. Access to digital content was opened to all for free and copies of the invaluable print edition were distributed free to disaster shelters the day after the storm.
Judges said: “With round-the-clock coverage, the Press provided critical news updates, but also practical advice and guidance before, during and after the storm – even continuing to this day with a complete resource guide for a community on the road to recovery. The staff of the Press rose to the occasion.”
Finalists
Detroit Free Press
Jennifer Dixon, staff writer; Brian Kaufman, photographer/videographer
For The Detroit Free Press’ hard look at the former Packard Plant, where the last car was built in 1954. It has become the biggest blighted property in a city often associated in the national mindset as a symbol of urban decay. In part because of the danger it presents and in part because it is “a convenient visual for anyone who wants to display the down side of the city,” the Free Press concluded: “It’s got to go.”
Judges said: “Stunning visuals and video from Brian Kaufman, complementing strong document-based reporting and interviews by Jennifer Dixon, may serve as a catalyst for action. Up against any other competition, this was first-place work.”
The Tennessean at Nashville
Staff
For mobilized coverage by The Tennessean staff that told the story of heart-breaking consequences during a fungal meningitis outbreak. The Volunteer State led the nation in the number of deaths from the outbreak traced to contaminated steroids commonly used for treating back problems.
Judges said: “Through its coverage, community forums, social media outreach and editorials, The Tennessean staff provided critical support to individuals at risk and raised important public health questions leading to change at the state level.”
The Des Moines Register
Carol Hunter, political editor
For a yearlong Des Moines Register public-service journalism project focused on understanding the challenges faced by children throughout Iowa.
Judges said: “The first four installments – poverty, hunger, single-parent homes and early childhood education – included consistent high-quality journalism mixing data with real-people approaches that made the content accessible. Each installment also includes a solutions segment, featuring ideas from experts.”
Division II
First Place
Springfield News-Leader
Kathryn Wall, Mark McCormick, Claudette Riley, reporters; David Stoeffler, executive editor
For the News-Leader’s ongoing Every Child public service project and its positive impact on moving the community to effect change.
Judges said: “The News-Leader’s ongoing Every Child series has done a great job of raising awareness about the critical issues facing children in Springfield, but the ultimate measure of any public service journalism project is whether it prompts positive change. The News-Leader’s tireless commitment to this project has done that and more. Its reporting has sparked a new community movement led by Springfield’s mayor and top leaders of four key institutions — the United Way of the Ozarks, Community Foundation of the Ozarks, Community Partnership of the Ozarks and the Springfield Public Schools. 
Inspired by the News-Leader’s dogged reporting, strong editorials and candid columns by Executive Editor David Stoeffler, the five community leaders formed a coalition named after the News-Leader’s Every Child project to tackle the issues contained in the newspaper’s special reports. The group has committed to developing an early childhood initiative and a long-range strategic plan and funding a paid staff position to ensure the coalition’s work stays on track. The ultimate goal, as stated in a News-Leader editorial: ‘Make our community a great place for kids, where every child grows up safe, happy, healthy and successful.’ Thanks to the News-Leader, the community is taking bold steps to work more collaboratively to make that happen.”
Finalists
Poughkeepsie Journal
Mary Beth Pfeiffer, projects writer; Spencer Ainsley, director of multimedia; Chris Cusumano, interactive developer; Chrissie Williams, multimedia artist
For the Poughkeepsie Journal’s ongoing exposé of the poor tracking, testing and misdiagnosis associated with Lyme disease cases in New York state and across the nation.
Judges said: “Projects writer Mary Beth Pfeiffer strikes again with excellent in-depth reporting that is seen more often at much larger papers. In this project, she smartly teamed up with Spencer Ainsley, director of multimedia, Chris Cusumano, interactive developer and Chrissie Williams, multimedia artist, to extend her storytelling across multiple platforms through video, social media and graphics. Strategic outreach to post coverage links on a range of Lyme-driven Facebook pages, web sites and Twitter accounts increased engagement in significant ways. It’s a strategy other newspapers should consider, especially for topics that transcend geographic borders.”
Journal and Courier at Lafayette, Ind.
David Smith, audience manager/First Amendment, Sophia Voravong, courts/police reporter
For outstanding reporting that went beyond the tragic details of the accidental death of a two-year-old crushed by a car and revealed an inexpensive solution to save the lives of little ones facing similar circumstances in the future.
Judges said: “The Journal & Courier served its community well by digging into the details of a tragic accident and discovering a solution that will no doubt save lives. In investigating the death, reporters Sophia Voravong and David Smith learned that a manufacturer-installed $9 safety mechanism likely would have prevented the accident that claimed the life of a two-year-old who was playing with a gear shift while his mother was washing the car. The child fell out of the car after accidentally knocking the car out of park and was crushed by the front left tire as the car rolled down the driveway. The dynamic reporting duo shed significant light on why millions of cars today lack the inexpensive safety system despite the federal government’s knowledge of the problem.”
Argus Leader at Sioux Falls
Steve Young, reporter; Emily Spartz, photographer; Patrick Lalley, managing editor; Joel Brown, multi-media producer
For a comprehensive, month-long series of stories showing the dramatic and often heart-warming evolution of the Sudanese refugee population – and how it has been embraced by the rest of Sioux Falls – with a special focus on a former “Lost Boy” who went back to his village of Dunyal to provide help.
Judges said: “The month-long series ‘South Dakota to South Sudan’ is rich with detail about life in South Sudan because reporter Steve Young traveled there with the main subject, David Jal. The commitment of the Argus Leader and Young is evident from beginning to end and raised awareness about both old and new immigrants through great storytelling on all platforms, including photo galleries, video, slide shows, live chats and a community gathering.”
Division III
First Place
The Leaf-Chronicle at Clarksville
Philip Grey, military affairs reporter; Chris Smith, senior editor
For The Leaf-Chronicle’s special report about soldier suicides and the lack of support for soldiers returning home to Clarksville.
Judges said: “Reporter Philip Grey put it bluntly: Sgt. Justin Junkin came home with a ‘bomb inside his head.’ Grey’s profile on Junkin, who was deployed to Afghanistan with 101st Airborne Divison, was a wake-up call for the community. The special report pointed out the flaws in the Army’s current policies and culture, which allowed Junkin to deploy despite his hearing loss. When Junkin returned home, he was put on suicide watch, but the Army was not allowed to tell his spouse – a policy that The Leaf-Chronicle questioned with a poignant editorial. The special report and editorial lead to community action. Religious and civic leaders came together to form a special coalition to take on PTSD and prevent soldier suicides. The Leaf-Chronicle followed up on this effort through a round-table discussion broadcast live.”
Finalists
The Ithaca Journal
Staff
For the Ithaca Journal’s investigation into the city’s crumbling sidewalks, curbs, streets and guardrails that led to community outcry for change.
Judges said: “Alan Young-Bryant, a Cornell University doctoral graduate, died in Ithaca walking back to his hotel at night. He fell from a walkway on a stone recreational trail that was broken and pitted with a bent railing. After Young-Bryant’s death, The Journal set up a web page asking for the community to share addresses, photos and video of public hazards that need to be fixed. They promoted this special site through a column by Managing Editor Bruce Estes. The site collected 40 public hazards from the community. The Journal then created an interactive map and database of the trouble spots. This use of reporting, public discussion and user-generated content shows a commitment to public safety.”
Home News Tribune at East Brunswick
Staff
For The Home News Tribune’s job of highlighting local agencies that make a difference and collecting donations for its Needy Cases Fund charity.
Judges said: “The Home News Tribune raised more than $13,000 for its Needy Cases Fund, which helps community agencies deliver needed services such as healthcare, housing and food banks. Through great stories profiling different agencies and the difference they make, The Home News Tribune put a human face on the needs of their community. This is spot on for their ‘Caring Community’ passion topic.”
The Daily Advertiser at Lafayette, La.
Staff
For The Daily Advertiser’s coverage of poverty’s impact on education and public discussion leading toward positive change.
Judges said: “The Daily Advertiser shined a light on high poverty in schools and its effect on the community. The reporting went beyond statistics and asked school officials, parents and local organizations what could be done now to help poor students. The Advertiser then organized a public forum to open a dialogue and talk about uncomfortable topics of poverty and race. This allowed new voices to be heard and stereotypes to be put aside.”
In-Depth Journalism
Division I
First Place
The News Journal at Wilmington
Jeff Montgomery, Molly Murray, reporters; Dan Garrow, graphics editor
For a series of in-depth reports on the critical issue of climate change along the Atlantic coast. The issue is much more than an academic discussion for Delaware residents, who must decide how much money should be spent to hold back the sea, which is forecast to rise 20 inches along Delaware’s coast in the next 40 years – and by the end of the century could potentially threaten 10 percent of the state’s land mass.
Judges said: “Exemplary reporting from Jeff Montgomery and Molly Murray, complemented by strong infographics from Dan Garrow, help explain the broader context for climate change while focusing specifically on the implications for Delaware. The ongoing series tapped into reader interest following Sandy to explain what lessons could be learned from damage along the Jersey Shore – and how it may force a rethinking of possible solutions.”
Finalists
The Clarion-Ledger at Jackson, Miss.
Jerry Mitchell, staff reporter; Debbie Skipper, assistant managing editor
For reporter Jerry Mitchell’s in-depth investigative report into the death of one woman – and disappearance of two others – pieced together the portrait of a possible serial killer: Mississippi native Felix Vail.
Judges said: “Jerry Mitchell’s painstaking work – with the support of Assistant Managing Editor Debbie Skipper – turned up a minister’s interview with Vail’s now-dead son and led to a pathologist who concluded the 1962 autopsy of Vail’s first wife was botched. After the newspaper’s reports, local authorities reopened that drowning case and sought assistance from the FBI in investigating Vail – who has now, himself, disappeared.”
The Tennessean at Nashville
Nate Rau, reporter; Steve Harman and Jae Lee, photo/videographers; Michael Campbell, digital graphics editor
For The Tennessean’s in-depth report on concussions among young people. The report helped readers understand the complex intersection of our cultural fascination with sport and the growing understanding of the dangers of head injuries. Reporter Nate Rau worked with photo/videographers Steve Harman and Jae Lee, as well as digital graphics editor Michael Campbell, to produce a 10-page special section. The report incorporated a variety of stories and explanatory graphics, and was paired with a digital presentation of videos and other content, packaged in an easy-to-use format for parents, coaches and policymakers. Tennessee is one of 10 states that hasn’t passed model legislation on when students can return to play after a concussion.
Judges said: “This was a well-planned, well-executed package that undoubtedly caught the attention of parents and policymakers, and stands to reignite the debate on whether Tennessee goes far enough to protect its student-athletes from serious long-term injury.”
The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Dennis Wagner, senior reporter
For the mystery behind state game and fish agents’ effort to capture a rare, wild jaguar – leading to the animal’s eventual death. They claimed it was accidental, but celebrated the opportunity it presented to learn about behavior and habitat needs. In fact, the jaguar was snared intentionally by people eager to land a lucrative federal research project.
Judges said: “Senior Reporter Dennis Wagner’s source work and tenacity uncovered a deeper conspiracy and cover-up in the capture and death of the exotic cat, exposing misconduct and prompting public outrage.”
Division II
First Place
The Burlington Free Press
Adam Silverman, accountability editor
For a narrative story on how police tracked a serial killer across not only the lower 48 states but also Alaska.
Judges said: “Adam Silverman’s chronicle of a serial killer’s multi-year killing spree is fascinating. Silverman followed the story from Vermont to Alaska to Arizona and Texas in an effort to learn more about a man who killed a local couple and nearly got away with it. Silverman takes you on a journey across the country as he tells the riveting tale of Israel Keyes and how he was ultimately caught.”
Finalists
Poughkeepsie Journal
John Ferro, environmental reporter
For John Ferro’s detailed reporting of a 17-year long water contamination problem caused by the New York Department of Transportation and its effect on the community.
Judges said: “John Ferro took an anonymous tip and forged a path to find justice for a number of families struggling to have clean water fed into their homes. Ferro details how the New York Department of Transportation’s neglect led to road salt contaminating the groundwater. Ferro captured the emotional struggle of residents as they fight for a very basic necessity, clean water.”
Springfield News-Leader
Michael Gulledge, reporter; Jonathan Shorman, reporter
For a series analyzing 10 years of burglary data in Springfield. The series explored new crime trends.
Judges said: “Michael Gulledge and Jonathan Shorman crunch burglary data to explore the trend in the crime. The pair thoughtfully explains why burglaries are difficult to solve and how once victimized people tend to focus more on prevention. The graphics and breakouts explain what the crime is, the trend and how the trend compares to other similar-sized cities. The graphics paired with the detailed reporting about the crime victims conveys the more complex issue plaguing Springfield.”
The Times at Shreveport
Mary Nash-Wood, Vickie Welborn and Loresha Wilson, reporters
For an in-depth look at how magnet schools select students in Caddo parish.
Judges said: “Mary Nash-Wood, Vickie Welborn and Loresha Wilson tell a story where minority children are being left behind by the magnet schools in Caddo parish. Through personal stories and statistics they show how black children are underrepresented at magnet schools. Through the multi-day report they analyzed how this happened and highlighted other solutions to help correct the disparity.”
Division III
First Place
Battle Creek Enquirer
Justin Hinkley, reporter
For reporter Justin Hinkley’s continuing coverage of education in Battle Creek and how the school struggles reflect on the community.
Judges said: “More than stories about education, these are stories about kids, teachers, families and a community. Justin’s writing is clear and concise. He makes you understand why the issue is important and why you should care. He connects what is happening in the classroom to what is happening in the community and in the world.
His story about the student march was particularly compelling. Instead of trying to explain what the kids were thinking and why they were staging a silent protest, he lets them tell the story in their own words – on signs they silently carried through downtown Battle Creek.
He includes many voices to illustrate the tension in the community. And those who don’t want to talk or deal with the issue don’t get off the hook, as Justin pointedly documents their averted gazes as the student marchers pass by.”
Finalists
Home News Tribune at East Brunswick
Mark Spivey, Pamela MacKenzie, Joe Martino and Bob Makin, reporters
For reporting on the prolonged power outages and cleanup efforts in New Jersey after Superstorm Sandy.
Judges said: “These Sunday packages were thorough and well-sourced, offering lots of real voices along with those from local government and utility companies. As a reader, I could feel the frustration of residents who had been without power for up to two weeks and who anticipated being asked to pay more for what they considered substandard service.”
The Spectrum at St. George
Casie Forbes and Kevin Jenkins, reporters
For a series of stories on the controversy over the name of Dixie State College and the possibility that a name change might accompany the school’s new status as a university.
Judges said: “What’s in a name? In the case of Dixie State College, 100 years of history, emotional ties to a storied past and a community divide along religious, political and ideological lines.
The debate over changing the name of the local college is symbolic, and the series of stories sheds light on the obvious angst that exists in a community torn between a fierce loyalty to the way things have always been and a desire to grow and progress.
The reporters look at the issue from a variety of angles – history, money, racism, the LDS church – while always being mindful of who their readers are.
Readers were clearly engaged on this topic. The use of online polls and feedback was a nice touch and put readers at the center of the reporting and the search for solutions.”
The Daily Advertiser at Lafayette, La.
Amanda McElfresh, education reporter
For Amanda McElfresh’s report on the issue of school discipline, prompted by a dramatic increase in the number of arrests on public school campuses in Lafayette Parish.
Judges said: “Amanda McElfresh brings context and a new level of understanding to a tough and troubling issue. On its surface, the issue is that there are more behavior problems in the schools. But beneath that surface, she finds stakeholders with a common goal who are completely at odds about how to achieve it. School leaders want to keep kids in classrooms and off the streets; teachers are frustrated with their lack of discipline options and feel threatened by students who are aware of those limitations; police officers are forced to arrest children because it is the only course of action available.
For a topic that many are clearly reluctant to talk about, she manages to include multiple sources on all sides of the issue.
The report contains alarming data, balanced with the compelling voices of a community struggling to find a solution.”
Breaking News
Division I
First Place
Asbury Park Press
Staff
For putting a human face on one of the worst natural disasters to hit New Jersey in 190 years.
Judges said: “A lot of depth went into the continual breaking news coverage of Superstorm Sandy from video to social media. Asbury Park pushed the limits of each platform during the storm. The staff adapted to the storm by redesigning APP.com and created Storm Watch, an online resource center for Sandy coverage. They reminded readers in print, ‘If your power is out, you can reach us with a mobile connection at m.app.com and tablet.app.com.’
When a storm of this force hits its community, breaking news coverage doesn’t last a few hours – it last weeks. Asbury Park ramped up reporting as the storm was coming, kept it going during the intense moments of the storm and transitioning to the bigger questions of the cleanup. It’s a challenge to put a human face on breaking news, but the staff found a balance between tweets and in-depth coverage, creating a connection to their audience.
Reporters, editors and staff arranged their coverage around community resources such as evacuation announcements and shelter information. This created a direct voice to keep their audience informed and safe.”
Finalists
The Journal News at Westchester
Staff
For providing breaking news updates that helped citizens find resources during Superstorm Sandy, a storm that left its mark on metro New York.
Judges said: “Westchester’s micro-update approach provided a blow-by-blow breakdown of Superstorm Sandy. The staff transformed its homepage and platforms into hubs of real-time information. The staff’s use of live chat and social media to answer reader questions in real-time not only attracted new followers but built trust during a tragic event. Westchester’s @LoHud Twitter account was so prolific, it was flagged three times for exceeding Twitter’s rate limit.”
The Indianapolis Star
Bobby King, Matt Kryger, Ryan Sabalow, Jill Disis and staff
For the breaking news coverage of a gas explosion that destroyed a sleeping neighborhood, killing two and injuring seven people.
Judges said: “Covering breaking news on an extremely thin deadline for print is no easy task. Now show up to the tragic scene of a gas explosion at 11:05 p.m. This is the situation Indianapolis Star reporters and photographers faced. The staff was able to file a story for print, post multiple videos and provide continuous updates through the morning. Their timely efforts gave shape to this neighborhood tragedy.”
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Staff
For breaking the news that University of Cincinnati football Coach Butch Jones was leaving for the University of Tennessee.
Judges said: “Great beat coverage by Bill Koch and quick planning by the Enquirer staff lead to a wonderfully executed step-by-step breaking news story. Their coverage is a blueprint on how to successfully evolve a news tip into multiple story formats from live chats and video to social media reaction and a look at ‘what’s next?’ This approach to breaking news kept the story fresh and made it a talker.”
Division II
First Place
Poughkeepsie Journal
Staff
For Poughkeepsie Journal’s sweeping, real-time coverage of Superstorm Sandy.
Judges said: “The Poughkeepsie Journal did a masterful job of urgently serving its readers with breaking news developments and high-utility coping information under incredibly dire circumstances. The Journal maximized all platforms, including social networks, to provide critical information such as the availability of bottled water and dry ice, and road closure and power restoration updates. The Journal worked seamlessly with its readers to post timely updates to both Twitter and Facebook. The staff also made liberal use of LiveStream for broadcasting weather conditions, traffic and interviews with utility officials, and produced 18 videos showing the damage and sharing the experiences of people most affected. This is a textbook example of the way all Gannett newspapers should cover the extensive damage and power outages brought on by severe weather.”
Finalists
The Burlington Free Press
Staff
For coverage by the Burlington Free Press of Vermont connections to a serial killer’s jailhouse suicide in Alaska.
Judges said: “It’s a great example of how Twitter can be a useful news tip service. A Free Press editor who was home watching football on a Sunday evening spotted a tweet about a serial killer’s jailhouse suicide in Alaska. He quickly learned about a Vermont connection – the killer had confessed to abducting and killing a Vermont couple who vanished 18 months earlier – and began using Twitter himself to share the news. This was the beginning of two days of solid coverage of developments in the case, including the posting of five videos, some produced by the Free Press and others obtained by authorities in Alaska.”
The Post-Crescent at Appleton
Staff
For comprehensive coverage of the worst snowstorm to strike the Fox Valley in years.
Judges said: “When the snowstorm hit, Appleton attacked the story with a digital-first vengeance through video, photo galleries and updates on various platforms and social networks. The staff produced 15 videos on Day 1, with five more posted on Day 2, and three photo galleries included reader-submitted images. This was an aggressive all-staff effort that resulted in Appleton’s second-highest mobile traffic to date.”
St. Cloud Times
Staff
For late-night coverage of a Cold Spring police officer who was shot and killed while responding to a “welfare check” at an apartment.
Judges said: “St. Cloud did a fine job of jumping on a breaking news story late at night. The police officer was shot and killed shortly after 10 p.m. and St. Cloud’s night digital content producer dashed to the scene. He immediately began sending out Facebook and Twitter updates, followed by an online story, photos and video of a 3 a.m. press conference. Bravo!”
Division III
First Place
The News-Star at Monroe
Greg Hilburn, business editor; Sarah Eddington, reporter
For methodical coverage of a shocking crime – with an even more shocking twist.
Judges said: “Reports of a shocking crime started simply enough. A young black woman had been attacked – set on fire by three men who wrote threatening racist messages on her car in what appeared to be toothpaste. But the story would travel many twists and turns before the truth would be revealed. Reporter Sarah Eddington and business editor Greg Hilburn covered the story, from the initial information when the story broke to the rapidly changing events as the hoax was uncovered. Continuing coverage of the story examined social media and made key use of videos and photo galleries to document the unraveling as the story progressed.”
Finalists
The Spectrum at St. George
Casie Forbes, reporter; Trevor Christensen, photographer; Brittny Goodsell, assistant digital editor
For capturing an unexpected moment in a developing story about Dixie State College changing its name due to links to slavery.
Judges said: “While investigating components of a larger series on the currently named Dixie State College and the debate on its heritage, photographer Trevor Christensen chanced upon a Confederate-based statue being torn down on the campus to prevent vandalism – ostensibly in secret. Along with reporter Casie Forbes and assistant digital editor Brittny Goodsell, they were able to capture a pivotal story, video and photos for online and print.”
Home News Tribune at East Brunswick
Staff
For covering a rapidly changing natural disaster despite myriad obstacles.
Judges said: “Despite the many obstacles caused by Superstorm Sandy, the staff managed to capture the essence of the storm and keep residents informed. Stunning images and timely updates dotted overall digital and print coverage.”
The Marion Star
Kurt Moore, reporter
For a domestic violence call that took an unfortunate turn.
Judges said: “As the events of a domestic dispute unfolded overnight, Kurt Moore had to sort through the details as the initial report twisted to a fatal conclusion. The man killed by authorities in the incident was suspected to have committed ‘suicide by cop.’ Steady coverage included timely tweets along with the digital and print play.”
Outstanding Writing
Division I
First Place
Asbury Park Press
Stephen Edelson, columnist
For a collection of Stephen Edelson columns that revealed the human toll of Superstorm Sandy.
Judges said: “Edelson’s columns capture the heart and soul of a community left in ruins by Superstorm Sandy, and pay tribute to the power of the human spirit. Using vivid details, Edelson transports us to the neighborhood that existed before the storm and then abruptly drops us back into the devastation that is left behind. He lays bare the emotions of his subjects and we feel the human impact and the personal significance of each story. His evocative storytelling carries you through the grieving process – from shock to sadness and anger and ultimately to acceptance, strength and a commitment to move forward.”
Finalists
The Des Moines Register
Dan Finney, senior reporter
For a riveting report on the 20th anniversary of a brutal shooting at a diner near the Drake University campus.
Judges said: “Dan Finney’s writing is crisp and nicely paced as he chronicles a crime that shook the Drake University community. Divided into chapters, the story form keeps the lengthy narrative from being overwhelming. The drama of the crime and its aftermath is expressed in witness recollections, and Finney’s storytelling doesn’t try to compete with those. Instead, he propels the reader chronologically through the events, introducing details as the story unfolds. In the end, he adds a layer of context, describing how the community reacted to the horror. Instead of putting up fences to keep students and residents safe, they united and rededicated themselves to revitalizing the neighborhood.”
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Tiffany Lankes, education reporter
For Tiffany Lankes’ collection of three unrelated stories.
Judges said: “In the first two entries, Tiffany writes with authority about education issues facing Rochester. She looks at two schools only a mile apart that serve similar high-poverty student populations. One – a publicly funded charter school – is producing consistently high test scores and high-achieving students. The other – a traditional school within the city school district – continues to see declining performance among its students. The reasons for the performance gap are complex and there is a lot of data required to explain it. But Tiffany is a gifted storyteller, and manages to use the data to give a clear and engaging report. The second education story examines young black men and three paths available to them – the cemetery, the classroom or the cell block. Again, supported by statistics, she manages to put a face on the issue and tells a story with very human consequences.
In her third entry, Tiffany attends the wake of a murdered firefighter. In vivid detail, she brings the poignant scene to life.”
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Krista Ramsey, columnist
For a series of Krista Ramsey columns on a 68-year-old housewife and grandmother who goes on an eight-month bank robbery spree.
Judges said: “Krista’s curiosity about what would drive an elderly woman to put on a scarf and sunglasses and rob several banks results in a captivating tale of an insecure woman and a dysfunctional family. She really gets inside these characters and reveals what makes them tick. She uncovers the very human emotions that drove a woman to take extreme measures for the son she adored. We get to know the family so well – and really, they’re pretty darn normal folks – that we start to see ourselves in them. Despite the relatively serious nature of the crime, Krista’s conversational voice draws us in and keeps us engaged throughout the series.”
Division II
First Place
Springfield News-Leader
Claudette Riley, reporter
For a gripping serial narrative about the dramatic twists and turns in the hard life and tragic death of 14-year-old Trevor Reynolds.
Judges said: “Although this contest emphasizes just three days of a writer’s work, Claudette Riley’s eight-day serial narrative is so beautifully written that it’s impossible to stop reading. The writing includes outstanding visual imagery, descriptive detail that demonstrates dogged reporting and cliffhanger endings to each installment that leaves readers wanting more. The series also serves a higher purpose beyond reader engagement by helping the Springfield community better understand the complex challenges faced by too many children today. Well done Claudette and Springfield News-Leader!”
Finalists
Statesman Journal at Salem
Cara Pallone, storyteller reporter
For outstanding writing by Cara Pallone about a cluster of bone cancer cases through the eyes of one of its victims, 17-year-old Lisa Harder.
Judges said: “Writer Cara Pallone has a great eye for detail and uses just the right combination of words to describe a scene and character movement. Her technique often pulls the reader in, sometimes directly and sometimes indirectly, to imagine what living with cancer is like.”
‘Imagine being 21 years old and cancer is consuming your body. Imagine knowing that you probably will die. Imagine that your younger peers, who have the same type of cancer, are watching to see how your story ends.
‘What would you do?’
For this judge, it was very effective!”
Argus Leader at Sioux Falls
Steve Young, reporter
For graphic yet tasteful profile of child killer Donald Moeller, published two days before scheduled execution.
Judges said: “The lede by Argus Leader writer Steve Young is the most compelling of the entries. It starts with ‘Ken Albers couldn’t believe his eyes,’ and the description of the scene the county sheriff saw on that day prompted him do something very unusual at the crime scene. ‘It didn’t look real to me, so I had to touch her,’ Albers told Young. This speaks to the kind of surprising detail found in other parts of the story about the troubled life of murderer Donald Moeller. ‘The man who snatched innocence from a neighborhood in the shadow of the penitentiary was no novice to crime. Court records show that through his teen years and adult life, Moeller was a thief and a thug who tried to play out his sexual perversions at the point of a knife. His file reveals that he once chased down a man and punched him in the nose, convinced that the stranger had upset his dog as he walked past Moeller’s yard and caused the animal to bark.'”
Tallahassee Democrat
Jennifer Portman, senior writer
For a delightful narrative by Jennifer Portman about the challenges facing the Apalachicola, a river central to life for thousands of people and for species of rare plants and animals.
Judges said: “Jennifer Portman artfully weaved in layers of information about the challenges facing the Apalachicola while taking the reader on a lyrical ride down the river. Her narrative scene-setters opened up the doors of my reader’s mind so I could be on the river with her.”
Division III
First Place
News Journal at Mansfield
Mark Caudill, reporter
For the terrifying and honest story of a woman who was kidnapped at gunpoint while walking the family dog. Jennifer Hurst feared for her life. But the 12 hours she spent with her kidnapper ended peacefully as she was released unharmed in a downtown Cleveland parking lot. Following the sentencing of the kidnapper, Hurst shared her story with reporter Mark Caudill of the News Journal.
Judges said: “Persistence landed Mark Caudill an interview with kidnap victim Jennifer Hurst. His skillful reporting, and fluid writing, provided News Journal readers with rare insight into the fear, courage and dignity displayed by the kidnap victim. Caudill was able to get Hurst to recall vivid details about her experience, weaving together a gripping tale with a satisfying ending.”
Finalists
The Daily Advertiser at Lafayette, La.
Megan Wyatt, reporter
For the story of a fatal crash on the eve of Thanksgiving that left a local family with nothing but the remains of a beautiful 22-year-old daughter – and questions about the slow pace of justice for the repeat offender charged with vehicular homicide in the case.
Judges said: “Reporter Megan Wyatt’s descriptive writing and scene-setting provided readers with a story that rose above the normal for the all-too-familiar tale of the tragedy of drunk driving. Wyatt sensitively handles the family’s grief and frustration over why the man charged in the crime remains free.”
The News Leader at Staunton
Cindy Corell, community conversations editor
For three pieces that illustrate the breadth of Cindy Corell’s writing talent, but none more so than her in-depth feature, “Bond of Steel,” about how the wounds of war helped transform a young couple and bring them closer together.
Judges said: “Reporter Cindy Corell writes with authority, not relying on conventional approaches or a heavy mix of quotes. Her feature, ‘Bond of Steel,’ moves smoothly back and forth between the tragic injury facing an Army veteran and the emotional roller-coaster experienced by his wife.”
Iowa City Press-Citizen
Josh O’Leary, enterprise reporter
For reporter Josh O’Leary’s profile of a local icon known to everyone as ‘Smiley,’ that leaves readers happy, satisfied they know more about what makes this character tick. The profile was one of three examples showing the depth of O’Leary’s contributions for Press-Citizen readers.
Judges said: “With an unusual writing approach, Reporter Josh O’Leary lures readers into the world of Gary Bloore, better known to local residents as “Smiley” because of his ever-present grin. O’Leary helps us learn Bloore’s story through interviews with a host of others and through spending time with Smiley himself.”
Multimedia Storytelling
Division I
First Place
FLORIDA TODAY at Brevard
Rob Landers, digital producer and staff
For a yuletide stroll starting in the 1920s through Christmas past and present, the popular gifts, the music, the movies and the events that defined each period in the timeline.
Judges said: “This fun, creative idea from digital producer Rob Landers and the FLORIDA TODAY staff rethinks holiday immersion. The digital interactive timeline is impressive, with its addition of key events from each time period to help frame the holiday trivia and fill out the entries. The print feature is interesting as a standalone, but makes key use of a QR code and promo to direct readers to the main online elements, submitted videos and photos, staff videos and more.”
Finalists
The Des Moines Register
Sarah Day Owen, Juice editor
For a special augmented reality issue of weekly entertainment and lifestyle tab, Juice, from editor Sarah Day Owen.
Judges said: “Augmented reality was put to the test for the weekly entertainment and lifestyle tab, Juice. Through the lens of an iPhone app developed for the project, readers could interact with additional content for the section. These fun, interesting elements blended video, photo, quizzes, social media, events and other interactive material in an innovative, portable experience.”
Detroit Free Press
Brian Kaufman, photographer/videographer, and Jennifer Dixon, staff writer
For a look at the decline and ruins of the Packard Plant.
Judges said: “This retrospective series from photographer/videographer Brian Kaufman and staff writer Jennifer Dixon examining the ruins of the Packard Plant in Detroit and its history is haunting but hopeful. Stunning imagery, well-produced video, photo galleries and an interactive aerial map feature allow immersion into the accompanying stories and editorial about the future of the site. Additional social media elements encourage engagement for the series.”
The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Keira Nothaft, project leader; staff
For creating and launching an evening newsmagazine geared toward the tablet audience on iPad.
Judges said: “This newsmagazine from project leader Keira Nothaft and staff is an innovative approach to bringing current material to a new audience in a different but important format on the tablet. The interface for the newsmagazine and the images are clear, crisp and well-designed and encourage a new level of engagement and interaction from readers. In addition to the newsmagazine, judges also would like to acknowledge the staff’s multimedia work from election night. The election night coverage took a new approach to the topic, combining successful video and social media engagement into a timely package.”
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Lisa Bernard-Kuhn, health care reporter; Lee Ann Hamilton, business editor
For a multimedia look at 175 years of history of locally based mega-company Proctor & Gamble and its brands.
Judges said: “Photo galleries, quizzes, reader-contributed stories punctuated a special digital section devoted to documenting the vast history of Proctor & Gamble and its many brands. The various multimedia elements allowed different points of entry into learning about the company and its development over the years.”
Division II
First Place
Tallahassee Democrat
Staff
For election night coverage that pushed the limits of multimedia reporting.
Judges said: “The Tallahassee Democrat took on an all encompassing approach to cover the 2012 election. The staff utilized all of their tools to gather, report and analyze local and national results from beginning to end. This took coordination of live video, social media reporting and new digital story formats.
The use of live video and Skype allowed reporters in the field to break-in with updates and editors to do on-camera interviews with newsmakers and politicians. This multimedia approach went beyond winners and losers, voter turnout and politics as usual. Their efforts created a real-time discussion and greater context for the audience. The Democrat’s election coverage shows impact, speed and value on all of their platforms.”
Finalists
The Post-Crescent at Appleton
Sharon Cekada, photojournalist; Dwight Nale, visuals editor; Joel Christopher, digital content editor; Nick Penzenstadler, reporter
For The Post-Crescent’s investigation into an Appleton police officer, who shot and killed a man while on duty.
Judges said: “Appleton’s multimedia project, Code 1, puts the audience in the passenger seat on a ride-along to a police shooting. Their use of documents, audio and video tells an unfiltered and personal story of a tragic event. The audio and video editing keeps the story moving and highlights the most intense moments. This combination creates a sense of place.”
Poughkeepsie Journal
Chris Cusumano, multimedia designer; Irwin Goldberg, digital editor; Barbara Gallo Farrell, assistant local editor; Chrissie Williams, multimedia artist
For bringing to life the Poughkeepsie Journal’s “Scary Stories” contest. The contest invited kids to submit their original Halloween stories and illustrations. The journal received more than 300 entries.
Judges said: “Poughkeepsie’s Scary Stories project is pure bliss. The creativity and the concept is an example of how to take the evergreen theme of Halloween and do something completely unique.
The Poughkeepsie staff’s use of video, Flash and Photoshop brought the children’s scary stories to life. The site design and functionality keeps you engaged and the videos of each winner reading their story are adorable, in a scary way of course. This project is a reminder that we can tell great stories and have fun at the same time.”
Green Bay Press-Gazette
Andrew Pekarek, Prep’s View reporter
For Andrew Pekarek’s video storytelling style applied to local high school sports.
Judges said: “Green Bay’s Andrew Pekarek is not afraid to look funny, and that’s a good thing. His injection of personality and humor allows his videos and blog to cover high school sports in a different way for a different audience. Involving high school athletes in his gags changes the focus from your typical interview video approach.”
Division III
First Place
Battle Creek Enquirer
Barrett Newkirk, Jennifer Bowman and Justin Hinkley, reporters
For a series of interactive timelines that highlight stories from 2012 and stories to watch in 2013.
Judges said: “Barrett Newkirk, Jennifer Bowman and Justin Hinkley created three well executed timeline lines.. They seamlessly combined words, photos, videos and PDFs of the front page to visually draw the reader through the year’s top stories. The words provide the immediate information while the photos and videos provide the extra content digital viewers demand. The timeline allows the reader to see when the news happened and in relationship to other events. The timeline offered some surprises including the former governor’s appearance on a dating television show with video, of course.”
Finalists
The News Leader at Staunton
David Fritz, executive editor
For an interactive timeline that combines years of stories previously published on the weekly history page.
Judges said: “Wow! The volume of content is amazing. There are options on how to digest the content. You can use the timeline feature, click through Flipbook, a chronological list or locate stories a map to geographically choose the content. The News Leader could have created a traditional landing page for the section but they took their idea a step further by making the section a ‘choose your own adventure,’ which gave the reader a choice.”
Visual Journalism: Design
Division I
First Place
Detroit Free Press
Rick Nease, art director; Eric Millikin, multimedia and graphics director; Jason Karas, designer
For a series of posters celebrating the Detroit Tigers’ 2012 season.
Judges said: “Rick Nease designed three visually stunning posters. The posters used strong imagery but also used statistics to add depth and meaning to the posters. ‘Back2Back’ played off the Tigers having two MVPs in a row. The ‘Triple Crown’ poster used strong images of Miguel Cabrera but also listed his stats that won him the honor. The ‘We love the D’ by Eric Milikin and Jason Karas used more than 1,000 reader-submitted photos to design the poster. The illustration is eye-catching and the poster even provides a history lesson on the evolution of the Tigers’ logo.”
Finalists
Asbury Park Press
Suzy Palma, New Jersey design director, Asbury Park Design Studio
For a collection of pages from Superstorm Sandy and the November election.
Judges said: “Suzy Palma brings bold and exciting typography to her work. She used techniques to bring drama to her pages. On the Superstorm Sandy pages she allowed the amazing photography to carry the page, even wrapping one photo around the front and back of the page. It’s often difficult to wrap a picture around the paper but Palma found design solutions to make the two pages work as one. The political pages utilized strong color and illustrations to engage the reader in the complex topics of the national debt and health reform.”
The Journal News at Westchester
Joanne Sosangelis, design team leader, Asbury Park Design Studio
For a front page design honoring the victims of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting.
Judges said: “The striking A1 design by Joanne Sosangelis appropriately acknowledges the Christmas holiday while honoring the victims of the recent Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting. Sosangelis created a bold and stunning page by using minimal color and typography. The concept is brilliant and the execution was flawless. The words ‘A moment of silence from The Journal News’ are perfectly placed below the fold allowing the design to be about the victims. I would imagine that many of the readers did take a moment of silence to digest the complex simplicity of the front page.”
The Des Moines Register
Katie Kunert, digital artist; Mark Marturello, cartoonist
For a printed poster and digital interactive look at Iowa football coach Kirk Ferentz’s 100 wins.
Judges said: “The printed poster and digital interactive stand on their own but also complement each other. The printed poster visually illustrates where the highs and lows were of Ferentz’s career at Iowa. The poster integrates photography with strong typography. The digital interactive takes you year-by-year and game-by-game through each win. Each slide was well-organized and included a photo, game summary and link to the past coverage resulting in a nice trip down memory lane.”
The Courier-Journal at Louisville
Jeff Patterson, designer
For two preseason college basketball previews.
Judges said: “Jeff Patterson and the Louisville sports department created a ‘re-election’ theme for the college preview sections. The theme was carried through the section and encouraged you to vote for your favorite team. Design elements worked as a navigational tool to guide the reader through the sections. The section contained design elements to surprise and entice the reader as they prepared for the 2012-13 college basketball season.”
Division II
First Place
Wausau Daily Herald
Sean McKeown-Young, Wisconsin design team leader; Peter J. Wasson, assistant managing editor
For design that pops off the front-page of The Wausau Daily Herald.
Judges said: “Des Moines Design Studio designer Sean McKeown-Young’s collaboration with Wausau Assistant Managing Editor Pete Wasson paid off. McKeown-Young’s design work is big and bold. His front-page designs create a dominant focus that pulls you in. The front pages show a diversity of illustrations, graphics and maps. It is very clean and to the point, allowing the reader to grab added information from the design.”
Finalists
The Burlington Free Press
Danielle Morris, Asbury Park Design Studio; Nicole Haley, ARTSbtv section editor; Adam Silverman, Green Mountain section editor; Ryan Mercer, photo editor
For design of a special Green Mountain & Arts section on recycling and reuse in Vermont.
Judges said: “This special section is filled with resourceful visuals. Literally. Designer Danielle Morris, section editor Nicole Haley, Green Mountain section editor Adam Silverman and photo editor Ryan Mercer integrated the reuse theme through fun section headers, typography and photography.”
Argus Leader at Sioux Falls
Argus Leader and Des Moines Design Studio staff
For clean and powerful design of the Sen. George McGovern Special Commemorative Section in the Argus Leader.
Judges said: “The Des Moines Design Studio and Sioux Falls Argus Leader’s use of historical photos and white space pay tribute to former Sen. George McGovern. No tricks were needed, just smooth and steady design principles capture the importance of McGovern to South Dakota. The last page of the section is a perfect reflection of this subtle yet impactful presentation.”
Poughkeepsie Journal
Michael Grant, Asbury Park Design Studio; Poughkeepsie Journal staff
For the layered design of Poughkeepsie Journal’s “Players” recreational sports section.
Judges said: “Asbury Park Design Studio designer Michael Grant and Poughkeepsie Journal section editor Mike Benischek captured a sophisticated vibe for the ‘Players’ recreational sports section. Each section front weaves together illustrations, graphics and content to create a piece of informative art.”
Division III
First Place
Home News Tribune at East Brunswick
Jennifer Meyer, feature designer, Asbury Park Design Studio
For a selection of section front pages by Jennifer Meyer for a weekly food section, Table.
Judges said: “Jennifer Meyer’s section front designs for Table nicely weave graphics, statistics, photos and stories for the weekly food section. Each cover is redrawn and re-imagined, usually tying into that week’s material, such as when a snack survey centerpiece featured several snack images to offset the survey results and additional points of entry for the package.”
Finalists
Times Herald at Port Huron
Paul Costanzo, sports writer; Michael Eckert, editor
For a fun approach to tracing the path from high school dreams to playing college football.
Judges said: “In order to best illustrate the path from high school football player to successful recruitment into the college program, Paul Costanzo and Michael Eckert actually drew a path – resembling a board game – around the print story showing each step of the process. The approach was fun and a quick way to access the information. Also, should a reader wish to remember the important steps of recruitment, the design easily could be cut out and tucked away for future reference.”
The Daily Advertiser at Lafayette, La.
Kristin Askelson, managing editor, and Scott Lester, design team leader, Des Moines Design Studio
For a jarring look at violent behavior in schools and rise in arrests.
Judges said: “Juxtaposing an image of a young child in handcuffs with the feature story, Kristin Askelson and Scott Lester strongly illustrate the seriousness and scope of the rise in arrests, violence and disciplinary issues at the schools – even among the younger students – and the concerns such trends provoke.”
News Journal at Mansfield
David Kennard, managing editor
For graphic illustration and design on the walnut twig beetle, which has been responsible for killing vast areas of forest.
Judges said: “The thoughtful illustration paired with the story allows readers to more easily access key information about the walnut twig beetle and its devastating damage that could potentially threaten local foliage. David Kennard’s design shows the dangerous insect, the states in which the tiny bug has left a wake of destruction and the damage it causes. The graphic allows for bite-sized (no pun intended) access points to the story’s overall message.”
Visual Storytelling: Photo/Video
Division I
First Place
Asbury Park Press
Tanya Breen, staff photographer
For photographic coverage of Superstorm Sandy.
Judges said: “Staff photographer Tanya Breen captured not only the property destruction from Superstorm Sandy but also, the emotional toll. From a picture of a house defying the laws of gravity to people salvaging their belongings from their crumbled homes, Breen’s images leave you feeling sympathetic toward the community for their loss.”
Finalists
The Des Moines Register
Chris Gannon, photographer
For Chris Gannon’s photography and video footage of “Iowa Heroes: A Salute to World War II Veterans.” The project featured 10 veterans from across Iowa who shared their stories about the war.
Judges said: “Photographer Chris Gannon captured the essence of these 10 World War II veterans in both photo and video. The photographs show men weathered by history. Listening to the veterans described their experiences in war, why they fought and the lasting impact of the war on not only them but their families provides perspective on history. While the photographs drew me into the videos, the videos let me wanting to learn more about these amazing men.”
The Courier-Journal at Louisville
Michael Clevenger, staff photographer
For a series of video and photography.
Judges said: “Michael Clevenger knows video. As the video begins it is clear that Clevenger had a plan for shooting the video. His use of cut-always, light, music and time-lapse effects keep the viewer engaged and wondering what will happen next. His videos evoke emotion, as readers watch the house move down the road coupled with music selection that lifts the mood to excitement.”
The Indianapolis Star
Matt Kryger, photographer
For photographic coverage of a gas explosion that leveled an Indianapolis neighborhood. The gas explosion killed two people, injured seven, damaged 80 houses and displaced 200 people.
Judges said: “Matt Kryger’s photographs help convey the size of the news event. The pictures of firefighters battling the blaze have a surreal feeling as the ‘for sale by owner’ sign sits in the foreground. Kryger stayed on site for hours covering the explosion and after a quick rest followed up the breaking news photography with an image from overhead that illustrated the scoop of the explosion in the morning light. The images alone tell a very compelling and tragic story.”
Division II
First Place
Green Bay Press-Gazette
Evan Siegle, photojournalist
For Evan Siegle’s photographs and multimedial slideshow from the sidelines of Green Bay Packers games.
Judges said: “Evan’s images are compelling and artistic. From game action to players’ emotions, each shot tells a story. On road games, he also brings to viewers the flavor of city and the venue. His weekly slideshow is a great example of engagement and branding. Evan’s personality shines as he gives a behind-the-scenes account of each game. What a treat for Packers fans.”
Finalists
Poughkeepsie Journal
Chrissie Williams, multimedia artist
For Chrissie Williams’ photos, video and story on mothers who choose to give birth at home.
Judges said: “Chrissie is a true multimedia journalist. She clearly gained the trust of her subjects and she told their stories – in words and images – with clarity and compassion. It was compelling work, sharing with the audience the most intimate moments of these families’ lives. And while the comprehensive package had plenty of warm and tender moments, it had a firm foundation based on data and thorough reporting.”
Springfield News-Leader
Dean Curtis, multimedia editor
For Dean Curtis’ package of photos and videos on a school bus crash.
Judges said: “Dean’s images capture raw emotion – fear, love and relief – on the faces of the children, parents and bystanders. It was a relief to learn none of the children were seriously injured. His work is a great example of breaking news with an iPhone, as he was able to quickly get to the scene and get the story and images to readers as the situation was developing. This is how mobile journalism should be done.”
Montgomery Advertiser
Mickey Welsh, staff photographer
For a series of unrelated Mickey Welsh photos and videos that capture slices of life around Montgomery.
Judges said: “Photographer Mickey Welsh has a keen eye for capturing ‘the moment’ in each of his still images. There’s drama, emotion and action in his diverse collection. Each image is compelling and together they give readers a definite sense of place. His videos are a nice complement to the still work, as he finds interesting personalities and charming slices of life.”
Division III
First Place
Home News Tribune at East Brunswick
Jason Towlen, staff photographer
For staff photographer Jason Towlen’s images and videos in the aftermath of Superstorm Sandy.
Judges said: “The images of Superstorm Sandy’s destruction are striking, but the stunning videos add an element of coverage that could not be achieved in print or a simple photograph. Interviews, voice narration and sweeping video work are blended seamlessly in the submitted works.”
Finalists
Gannett Wisconsin Media
Staff
For Gannett Wisconsin Media’s user-submitted videos, which honor Green Bay Packers’ quarterback Aaron Rodgers. The idea was initiated and gained steam in Stevens Point, and carried forward by the digital team in Green Bay so it could be used by Gannett Wisconsin Media properties throughout the state.
Judges said: “In response to a push for Dec. 12, 2012, to be named ‘Aaron Rodgers Day’ for the popular Green Bay Packers quarterback, readers were asked to submit videos as part of a series saying why they adored him. The videos – and additional social media elements – were a fun approach to the story and encouraged reader interaction.”
The Town Talk at Alexandria
Melinda Martinez, photojournalist
For a selection of photo pages from photojournalist Melinda Martinez on community life in Alexandria.
Judges said: “From zombies to heritage, intriguing photos from Melinda Martinez are on display on visual diary pages. The photo spreads capture snapshots of the events chronicling community life.”
Star-Gazette at Elmira
Jason Whong, staff writer
For images from staff writer Jason Whong documenting the processional for fallen Army Spc. Ryan Jayne.
Judges said: “Jason Whong’s moving images from the processional for fallen soldier Army Spc. Ryan Jayne capture the ceremony and somber emotion of an event steeped in tradition.”
The Advocate at Newark
Zach Gray, photographer
For Zach Gray’s video story covering Newark Catholic’s state championship football game.
Judges said: “Zach Gray’s well-produced video ties clean audio overlay, image and game play into a neat package documenting the Newark Catholic football team gearing up for the game – and the team’s eventual loss.”