Sophisticated Video, Innovative Storytelling Methods Highlight First-Quarter Awards of Excellence
The first-quarter Awards of Excellence show newsrooms across the company are fast becoming expert video storytellers and are innovating new ways to gather and publish content. They are doing so while remaining committed to our highest purposes – public service and watchdog journalism. Journalists called attention to critical issues facing their communities, prompting change for the good.
In public service, Rochester raised the community dialogue about the root causes of institutionalized racial inequality; Reno examined historical beginnings of why some local schools flourish while others fail; Monroe tracked what can happen when critical public services are shut down in budget battles.
Our watchdog work was as strong as ever. Asbury Park revealed to readers the shady dealings of charities in the wake of Superstorm Sandy; Gannett Wisconsin Media offered its audience a sophisticated analysis of public workers’ salaries in the wake of the legislative showdown on collective bargaining; Oshkosh unraveled the reasons behind and consequences of grade inflation at the local university.
Contest judges celebrated the vast improvement in both quality and quantity of video journalism, as compared to quarters past. This shows not only the dividends from USCP’s investment in iPhones and the #turbovideo training, but also underscores how seriously our journalists have taken those tools and how well they’ve put them to work. “The level of quality was off the charts,” one judge said. “So many were worthy of acknowledgement. For production value, some were like watching a television show.”
The Military Times’ essay of a unique tribute to those fallen in Afghanistan captured what is truly possible in video. In Bridgewater, the staff captured the passion at a high-interest local trial, showing how video can enhance breaking news coverage.
Some of the best work submitted this quarter foreshadows another area where we hope training and commitment help us vault forward: content programming. In Detroit and Phoenix, readers were served better than ever with coverage specifically designed for the time of day and platform on which it was presented. In both the breaking news and planned content categories, it was evident these two newsrooms understood their target audiences and bent over backward to deliver coverage that exceeded readers’ expectations. As each of our newsrooms moves toward its digital “re-launch,” including the introduction of a new native iPad app and the Presto publishing toolset, our journalists will receive training designed to help them frame our content for the best content experiences that our readers demand.
This quarter we added or revived several categories, including those on beat coverage, innovation and content programming. Each of these additions is designed to emphasize the fundamentals we value in our journalism, while encouraging our newsrooms to adapt those fundamentals to evolving reader habits and expectations. That said, the categories can and should be refined. If you have thoughts on how to improve these categories, please call or write Mackenzie Warren.
Top performing sites were:
- Division I: Detroit (6); Phoenix and Rochester (5 each)
Division II: Jackson, MS, Poughkeepsie and Sioux Falls (4 each)
Division III: Bridgewater, Jackson, TN, and Newark (3 each)
Design Studios: Des Moines (3); Asbury Park and Nashville (2 each)
Judges
Judges for the first quarter were: Michael Babin, design team leader for Nashville Design Studio; Jamie Mara, managing editor, The Post-Crescent at Appleton; Justin Hinkley; education reporter, Battle Creek Enquirer; Nicole Carroll, vice president/news and executive editor, The Arizona Republic at Phoenix; Irwin Goldberg, digital editor, Poughkeepsie Journal; David Davis, managing producer of digital immediacy, Statesman Journal at Salem; Michael McCarter, director of visuals – Enquirer Media, The Cincinnati Enquirer; Ben Lanka, enterprise editor, Newark/MNCO.
Prize money
First Place winners receive the following prizes: For a First Place award where the newsroom is cited, the newsroom gets $250, through intercompany deposit. If an individual is named in the First Place award, that individual gets $250 through a payroll deposit. Up to four individuals may be cited and they will split the $250 prize. For winning entries that cite five or more staffers, the $250 will go to the newsroom.
Dates for Q2 contest
Call for entries will be June 26
Submission deadline will be July 12
Judging will be July 22-25
To nominate a judge for this or future quarters, call Mackenzie Warren.
Categories
Please see this link for a complete description of the categories as newly defined in 2013. To recommend adjustments for this quarter, call Mackenzie Warren.
Public Service Journalism
Division I
First Place
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Staff
For “Unite Rochester,” a project and community conversation about racial attitudes, the importance of inclusiveness and the role race plays in employment and housing. The project included a proprietary poll that went deep into complex feelings about race and the community. The conversation occurred on all platforms and social media outlets, encouraging the community to join.
Judges said: “Rochester took on this project to promote awareness about racial issues and to talk about and discover more inclusive ways to solve community problems. Their approach is thoughtful, frank and collaborative. They used their considerable news and editorial resources to shine a light and offer solutions. The result: Outstanding public service.”
Finalists
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Staff
For the Cincinnati Enquirer staff’s project bringing to light the growing problem of heroin abuse and overdoses in greater Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky. The four-day project charted the history of prescription drug abuse that led to the rise of heroin and profiled the impact on individuals and families. The project has experienced continued life by community groups looking to understand the issue.
Judges said: “This package grabs the reader immediately with a compelling mix of storytelling, watchdog and data reporting. Each aspect of the topic is given appropriate attention to keep from feeling too dry or lacking in detail. The reader response speaks volumes about the value they feel the project had for the community.”
Asbury Park Press
Dustin Racioppi, staff writer
For “A Blind Eye,” an investigation into substandard and unsafe housing that was overlooked by lax inspectors. Reporter Dustin Racioppi took a certified housing inspector to several rental homes in heavily immigrant neighborhoods. All would have failed proper inspections. He then checked township records which showed the homes had passed inspection, or had not been inspected at all, even though they were approved for rental.
Judges said: “After the report, town officials went on “an enforcement tear.” In three weeks, they issued overcrowding citations, certificate of occupancy violations and deemed a dozen homes unsafe and ordered residents to leave. The town also hired an additional inspector. This reporting made a real difference. Without it, these families would still be living in unsafe conditions.”
Division II
First Place
Reno Gazette-Journal
Siobhan McAndrew, reporter, and staff
For a special report that looked at the 13 lowest-performing schools in the Reno area, challenges they face and the support they need. The series called on the public and government officials to do better by these schools, advocating for reforms, leadership and community action. Reno published a list of specific things each school needed – volunteers, mentors, assistants, and books – and encouraged the community to dive in and help.
Judges said: “Reporter Siobhan McAndrew and the staff didn’t just focus on the failing schools. They also showed schools with similar low-income populations but exceptional results so others could learn from these “no excuses” campuses. Also, because 24 percent of the schools’ elementary students are English-language learners, Reno published the report in both English and Spanish so the entire community could access the information. ”
Finalists
Poughkeepsie Journal
John Penney, community conversations/opinion editor
For “Voting: Make it Count,” a series of news stories and editorials that showed the issues surrounding and possible solutions for low voter turnout. This important work dug into issues such as student voting, redistricting, and allegations of tampering with voting records and galvanized support for reform.
Judges said: “Kudos to Poughkeepsie for taking this on. Protecting the public’s right to vote, and encouraging more to do so, is a vital public-service. Their focus on spreading the word to different audiences on different platforms was the right thing to do for the readers and the community.”
The Clarion-Ledger at Jackson, Miss.
Marquita Brown, Billy Watkins, Dustin Barnes, Ruth Ingram, Emily Lane, staff writers; Annie Oeth, features editor; Sam Hall, audience manager; and Debbie Skipper, assistant managing editor/news and business
For the Clarion-Ledger staff’s look at Mississippi’s impending charter school legislation. While legislators argued the specifics and fine points of a bill the Clarion-Ledger staff broke down what was at stake for school districts, the fine points of for-profit vs. non-profit schools, and editorialized on the potential impacts.
Judges said: “Cutting through rhetoric and presenting education topics in a clear manner is the goal when covering a topic as charged as education reform. The package presented by the Clarion-Ledger helped engage readers in an otherwise difficult to navigate topic and maintain focus on the problem this legislation was intended to alleviate.”
Division III
First Place
The News-Star at Monroe
Staff
For the News-Star’s coverage and editorializing on the growing issue of lack of animal control in their community. Building from an initial incident the paper continued coverage of animal attacks, an expanded look at the shelter system, and editorials calling for the city to hire an animal control officer.
Judges said: “With municipalities forced to make tough budget cuts, those decisions can have real consequences that may not seem obvious. The News-Star staff showed great attention by going beyond the incident facts to exposing the root of the issue and presenting its full size.”
Finalists
The Leaf-Chronicle at Clarksville
Lester Black, reporter; Chris Smith, senior editor
For an investigation that revealed inconsistent or improper approvals for cluster zoning of residential developments. One person accused of misusing the zoning was Councilman Jeff Burkhart. In addition to examining the problem, the Leaf-Chronicle wrote an editorial encouraging the council to clean up the inconsistencies but keep the constructive parts of the zoning ordinance intact.
Judges said: “The Leaf-Chronicle dove into a complicated topic and made it understandable. This issue is important to quality of life for the community and it was important to push the council to clean up the zoning language. Kudos for taking it on.”
Courier News at Bridgewater
Everett Merrill, staff writer
For a deep look into “Interdistrict School Choice,” a system that allows kids to transfer schools for academic purposes, but has caused an imbalance in school athletics. The Department of Education argued that these student-athlete transfers should not have to sit out 30 days like other transfers. The state’s athletic association argued otherwise, citing the imbalance. Reporter Everett Merrill examined the merits of both arguments.
Judges said: “The report was thorough and balanced, looking critically at the issue, the regulations, and the heated opinions on both sides. As a direct result of the report, the DOE changed its position and decided to make student-athlete transfers wait the 30 days. Assemblyman Patrick Diegnan wrote a letter praising the work, saying the enforcement of the 30-day rule ‘preserves the integrity of school sports programs throughout New Jersey.
Watchdog Journalism
Division I
First Place
Asbury Park Press
Shannon Mullen, staff writer
For a thorough investigation into the hard-to-crack inner workings of the world of charitable foundations.
Judges said: “From a field of top-notch watchdog reporting, Shannon Mullen’s reporting on the questionable practices of Hurricane Sandy relief charities rose above for tackling the hard-to-penetrate world of nonprofits, holding accountable organizations gathering millions of dollars from across the country and beyond, and for exposing the sometimes petty claims for credit that exist in the business of ‘helping others.’ It led to real differences not just for the donors but for the needy recipients of those funds.”
Finalists
The Indianapolis Star
Ryan Sabalow and Tim Evans, reporters
For a multi-faceted investigation into questionable land deals of a state highway project, the state laws surrounding such deals and the oversight of federal infrastructure investments.
Judges said: “Tim Evans and Ryan Sabalow’s extensive investigation of questionable land deals on a state highway project stood out among a crop of fantastic watchdog entries for the thoroughness of its reach. Evans and Sabalow looked not only at the local scandal of a state official benefitting from taxpayer investment, but at the state law that helped keep those deals in secret and at the national implications of federal investments in state projects. Taxpayer money was protected because of this team’s dogged hunt for every angle of this story.”
The Des Moines Register
Clark Kauffman, investigative writer
For a series of investigative stories revealing that the University of Iowa was sharing personal and federally protected student information with a sheriff as he considered requests for gun permits.
Judges said: “Few things are more important to people than their privacy. This is what made Clark Kauffman’s revelations so infuriating and compelling. Using some 2,000 email records, Kauffman exposed highly questionable practices and pressed officials for answers. Almost immediately those officials stopped what they were doing. This speaks to the power of the reporting.”
Division II
First Place
Gannett Wisconsin Media
Eric Litke, reporter; John Ferak, Gannett Wisconsin Media Investigative Team editor
An exhaustive series of stories that created an encyclopedic record of public employee salary data, and an intelligent analysis of the implication of those numbers, for Wisconsin readers.
Judges said: “Through obviously painstaking and meticulous work, Gannett Wisconsin Media has given its readers – and its Gannett colleagues – a virtual encyclopedia of data to help frame what had been an emotionally charged debate about the merits of public pay in terms of hard numbers and not preconceived notions. Packaged with spot-on analyses, the package helped readers draw their own conclusions about the role of public employees in their community. And you can’t get much more local than being able to flip a page in your local paper to see what your child’s teacher earns.”
Finalists
Reno Gazette-Journal
Martha Bellisle, investigative reporter
For a comprehensive look at the lax enforcement of Nevada gun laws that included data and case studies to show gaps in a system being debated by the nation.
Judges said: “As the nation clamored back and forth in the gun-control debate with beliefs fueled by ideology and emotion, Martha Bellisle and the team at the Reno Gazette-Journal dug into multiple sources to give their readers data and case studies that revealed the inarguable truth that existing gun laws are not properly enforced. Reno readers can speak with more authority to their lawmakers because of Bellisle’s comprehensive work.”
Springfield News-Leader
Amos Bridges, reporter; Dave Iseman, assistant managing editor
For a public records-based two-day series that untangled a mess of a local transportation project and the unsettling conduct of public officials.
Judges said: “This effort had all the hallmarks of great local watchdog reporting: public records, public money and public officials acting unsavorily. Amos Bridges and Dave Iseman’s spunky reporting dug to the bottom of a $3 million transportation project. An online interactive timeline helped readers navigate a complex issue, and a forceful editorial pushed for improvements. The reporting led the city to revisit training for employees. ”
Division III
First Place
Oshkosh Northwestern
Adam Rodewald, senior reporter
For an analytical piece exploring the often-discussed and rarely-examined issue of classroom grading.
Judges said: “Adam Rodewald stood out among his peers for a comprehensive look at an often-discussed but rarely-examined subject in his pieces “Inflated Grades” and “The Big F.” Rodewald clearly articulates the potential consequences of the issue for his readers. And, by inviting columns from UWO officials, the Oshkosh Northwestern fostered a community conversation about a topic near and dear to many parents’ hearts.”
Finalists
The Daily Advertiser at Lafayette, La.
Claire Taylor, senior reporter
For two Sunshine Week packages – one that checked judges’ public expenses, and the other that tested public records laws among local government agencies, with the help of college students.
Judges said: “Sunshine Week presents a great opportunity for watchdog reporting, and Claire Taylor seized it. Gritty work by Taylor, some with the enlisted help of college students, held officials accountable for both their compliance with public records laws and their use of taxpayer money. This was reporting that opened eyes during an important week.”
The Advocate at Newark
Jacob Kanclerz, reporter
For a numbers-based report about crime trends in a neighborhood plagued by vandalism and theft.
Judges said: “This was solid, fundamental watchdog reporting. When police said one thing, Jacob Kanclerz checked for himself and found something different. His use of public records related to neighborhood crime along with voices of those affected resulted in a more thorough understanding of an important community issue.”
Innovation
Editor’s note: The innovation category was new for us this quarter. Of all categories, it attracted the fewest number of entries. While a few of the entries stood out to judges, not enough met the category criteria to award more than one citation in every division. This doesn’t necessarily suggest a lack of innovation, but rather a need to better define the category. If you have ideas making this category better reflect the innovations we are making, or should be making, call Mackenzie Warren to discuss.
Division I
First Place
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Carl Weiser, politics editor; Tom Auel, developer
For a “talk to your government” tool that allows readers to contact their elected officials directly from Cincinnati.com. The tool also sends copies of the emails to Enquirer reporters.
Judges said: “The entry presents an excellent way to learn how readers feel about their government. It provides a simple tool to contact public officials and gather feedback on government actions. The entry was noted especially for its simplicity and ability to be replicated across the company.”
The judges, however, all shared a concern about this first generation of tool: “One option gave contributors a confidentiality option that could actually tie the Enquirer’s hands, even if another source provided the same information on the record. But innovation often includes iterations that improve the original idea, and this effort to engage the public was fresh and inspiring.”
Finalists
The Des Moines Register
Andy Hamilton, sports reporter; Tommy Birch, sports reporter; Gary Lake, digital sports editor; Craig Johnson, digital interactive graphics; Chad Leistikow, sports editor; photo staff
For The Des Moines Register’s mobile-first coverage and real-time results of the March NCAA wrestling championships. The Register created brackets that could be viewed on mobile, tablet and desktop, delivering instant results for more than 700 matches over three days.
Judges said: “The Register focused on what the audience wanted – results – and how most people would want them: on their phones. They supplemented the real-time brackets with live blogging of injuries and upsets and videos that analyzed the standings.”
Division II
First Place
Fort Collins Coloradoan
Josh Awtry, executive editor
For Josh Awtry’s presentation of the potential impact of a ban on fracking within Fort Collins city limits. To create the presentation a video was recorded using mapped data that allowed for a visual representation of the quantity of wells within the area, showing a relative lack of drilling in the city.
Judges said:
Division III
First Place
The Advocate at Newark
Michael Lehmkuhle, multimedia editor
For Finding Faces, a fun way to connect a community’s past to its present. Multimedia editor Michael Lehmkuhle posts archive photos on the Newark Advocate site and asks for the community’s help in identifying the people or the event. He encourages readers to help to “unlock these little mysteries.”
Judges said: “This is a great idea. We know readers love history and mysteries and this combines the two. Who knows what great tales may come from this creative crowdsourcing?”
Beat Coverage
Division I
First Place
The News Journal at Wilmington
Cris Barrish, Melissa Nann, Burke Esteban, Parra Sean O’Sullivan, reporters
For a package of stories that leveraged the reporters’ strong beat reporting to connect dots, fill in blanks and tell stories for Wilmington readers in a way no other news outlet could accomplish.
Judges said: “Competing against strong entries from throughout its division, the News Journal’s coverage of a courthouse murder-suicide made it clear that reporters Chris Barrish, Melissa Nann Burke, Esteban Parra, Sean O’Sullivan and Adam Taylor are masters of their beats and their communities. When officials were not forthcoming, they worked their sources to get answers for their readers. As the shooting linked back to previous court cases, they used their archives and institutional knowledge to take the story full-circle for their readers. Their mastery of their beats made a complete, expertly written and strikingly presented package come together quickly for their readers.”
Finalists
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Karen Miltner, food reporter
For a collection of stories, videos and social media work representing an emerging brand called RocFlavors – based on a commitment to satisfy readers who are passionate about food and drink.
Judges said: “Karen Miltner’s work has the ingredients for outstanding beat coverage in today’s competitive and multifaceted media environment. Under Rochester’s RocFlavors brand, Miltner mixes mastery of the topic, multiplatform delivery and audience engagement to serve up what a key audience is demanding. From kitchen tips and healthy recipes to a food/drink book club and features, she’s creating an exclusive passion topic experience for readers in words, video and more. A partnership with a public radio/TV station strengthens the effort. ”
The Des Moines Register
Jason Clayworth, reporter
A series of investigations that look at how taxpayer money is spent, how state policies and laws are enforced or explained to the public, and more.
Judges said: “As the Des Moines Register’s government accountability reporter, Jason Clayworth consistently turns out the kind of deep, comprehensive and sometimes emotional stories that other papers manage far less frequently. Complete with interactive online databases, videos and compilations of his reports, his persistence pays off for his readers and brought him to the top of a very competitive category.”
Division II
First Place
The Clarion-Ledger at Jackson, Miss.
Geoff Pender, political editor; Jimmie E. Gates, legislative reporter; Marshall Ramsey, editorial cartoonist; and Sam R. Hall, audience manager, assignment editor and columnist
For consistent, authoritative and easy-to-read coverage of the Mississippi legislature that not only informed readers but told them why the news mattered and what they could expect in the future.
Judges said: “Among many strong entries in the Beat Coverage category, consistency, reporters’ authoritative reporting and a strong digital presence that added to print coverage became the deciding factor in which entries rose to the top. The Clarion-Ledger’s reinvigorated coverage of the state capitol scored high on each of those points. Geoff Pender, Jimmie E. Gates, Sam R. Hall wrote regular, easy-to-read analysis pieces that both reviewed what happened and why it mattered and helped their readers look forward, and Marshall Ramsey’s spot-on cartoons added a layer of personality to what could otherwise be a very dry beat.”
Finalists
St. Cloud Times
Kari Petrie, reporter
For an exhaustive analysis of St. Cloud neighborhoods and their importance to the city as a whole.
Judges said: “Kari Petrie’s coverage of St. Cloud neighborhoods, the personal stories therein and her analysis of their import to the city as a whole offered readers a new way to look at their community and the role they could play in making it better. Packaged with a deeply informative, easy-to-use and comprehensive digital presence, Petrie has provided her readers a clearinghouse of data they can revisit and use any time they want to address a community issue.”
Wausau Daily Herald
Shereen Skola, public safety reporter
For a selection of public safety-related enterprise reports.
Judges said: “Deep and exclusive best describe Shereen Skola’s work in this entry. Often using public records to break news, Skola produced thoughtful, high-impact journalism. All of the pieces contained strong context to the news. This body of work is impressive particularly having been produced in just three months.”
Division III
First Place
Battle Creek Enquirer
Justin Hinkley, reporter
For a selection of stories about race, achievement, social media and other topics that delve into the inner workings of local schools and their impact on children and the community.
Judges said: “Justin Hinkley’s expertise of what’s affecting local schools and how those schools affect the community shines through in this entry – wide-ranging work that included digital content. Data underpinned several of the stories, and authoritative writing, strong context and thorough analysis set them apart. Readers in Battle Creek know not only what is happening in their education system but, more importantly, why.”
Finalists
The News-Messenger at Fremont
Daniel Carson, reporter
A detailed, all-angle examination of an important community issue, the debate over whether to remove or repair the Ballville dam.
Judges said: “Daniel Carson’s deep knowledge of his beat was obvious in his coverage of the Fremont reservoir issues. Because of that knowledge and mastery, he was able to not only analyze what had already happened but tell his readers what was coming up and how those pending decisions would impact them.”
The Daily News Journal at Murfreesboro
Scott Broden, staff writer
For a multi-faceted look at the broad issues facing Murfreesboro-area communities and the impact those issues have on readers.
Judges said: “Scott Broden showed a mastery of his beat, not just of the goings-on in local government but in the larger issues at play and the impact those issues have on his issues. His authoritative reporting, especially in the “Wheel of Growth” series, looked at his beat from a broader point of view than day-to-day coverage and his readers are better-informed because of it.”
Content Programming: Breaking News
Division I
First Place
The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Staff
For coverage of a triple shooting at a Phoenix office building that left two men dead and a woman injured.
Judges said: “The Arizona Republic’s Twitter feed during the event made me feel like I was there. Every few minutes – sometimes less – there was new information, including photos from the scene. At 12:29 p.m., a summary video from the scene went up.
The desktop site was constantly updated.
When it came to the next day’s print edition, the Republic tied the shooting to coverage from the gun debate in Washington, creating a multi-story package. One leading with the office building deaths and the manhunt for the suspect; a second about Mark Kelly’s testimony during the U.S. Senate hearing on gun violence (Kelly is the husband of former Rep. Gabrielle Giffords who was shot in Tucson two years ago) and additional stories on who the victims were. Plus, there was a timeline.
This effort continued when the suspect was found dead from a self-inflicted gunshot wound several days later.”
Finalists
Detroit Free Press
Staff
For the Detroit Free Press’ handling of a guilty verdict in the public corruption trial of Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick. Every staffer pitched in to reach readers on every platform.
Judges said: “Detroit created a multi-page plan to cover this major news online, in print and via social and delivered on it. They stuck to the new news cycle, breaking the news first via Jim Schaefer’s blog and moments later sharing it on Twitter and Facebook via the brand accounts. Text push alerts were sent to app users.
The desktop site was changed to a graphic of the defendants and live blog from other courtroom with videos and photo galleries added as available.
The next day’s print edition focused not on the verdict, but on how the city must now move forward though a column by Editorial Page Editor Stephen Henderson. The 10-page section included coverage from every angle: Jury, judge, prosecutor, defense, community reaction and columnists.”
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Paul Daugherty, columnist; John Fay, reporter; Angel Rodriguez, sports editor; Nick Hurm, sports channel coordinator
For coverage of the announcement that Cincinnati will host the MLB All-Star Game in 2015.
Judges said: “The three followed the new news cycle by breaking the news on Twitter and then creating a Storify to gather reaction to the news.
Online, they added a prepared photo gallery of All-Star games in Cincinnati, a quiz and more to engage readers. The next day’s paper edition featured a look back at other Cincinnati-hosted All-Star games as well as the news of the coming official announcement.”
Division II
First Place
Poughkeepsie Journal
Staff
For staff coverage of a hostage-taking situation that left two people injured and one man in custody.
Judges said: “The staff broke the news on Twitter and Facebook within minutes of police activity beginning. Updates flowed as new information was learned and the homepage story was updated often with new or additional videos.
Staffers produced five videos from the day, starting with a quick, silent video of cops staging outside the home and ending with a voice-over-photos video that summarized the day’s events. In between, they interviewed the hostage-taker’s mom, covered a news conference and more.
The next day, in print, coverage switched to behind-the incident coverage. They learned the incident may have resulted from domestic violence, read neighborhood reaction and heard from police about how they handle hostage standoffs. The following day’s print edition led with an exploration of the suspect’s criminal history and how he was on probation.”
Finalists
Fort Collins Coloradoan
Trevor Hughes and Robert Allen, reporters; Dawn Madura and Rich Abrahamson, photographers and Josh Awtry executive editor
For coverage of the Galena Fire by Trevor Hughes, Robert Allen, Dawn Madura, Rich Abrahamson and Josh Awtry.
Judges said: “This team created compelling video from the early morning hours. Reporter Trevor Hughes did a standup with analysis on the concerns. Another, with shots from the scene provided some context. The standout was a GIS overview narrated by Josh Awtry that provided context of where the fire is, where firefighters were working and how it compared to the High Park Fire.
The print version Sunday showed readers the impact and demonstrated strong watchdog journalism by Hughes who examined why there was a shortage of air tankers to fight fire. The reason, many of them are privately owned and hadn’t been officially hired.”
Argus Leader at Sioux Falls
Staff
For Argus Leader staff coverage of a boy rescued from the falls while his rescuers perished.
Judges said: “Staff provided readers with a steady stream of information using text, photos and videos. The videos showed a nice progression: Raw video from the scene, an interview with the fire chief and an interview with the boyfriend of the woman who dove in to help the boy.”
Division III
First Place
The Jackson Sun at Jackson, Tenn.
Staff
For comprehensive coverage by staff of the storms that struck communities Jan. 30 and 31.
Judges said: “The staff knew storms were coming and began preparing readers with social media alerts about forecasts, charging their phones and compelling them to, ‘stay safe.’ Then they hit the streets during the storms to provide reports from each community using text, pictures and video.
Eight videos showed damage in different communities and four photo galleries did the same.
Print coverage moved from what happened to tips for homeowners, a damage assessment and tips for homeowners.”
Finalists
Hattiesburg American
Staff
For staff coverage of a tornado that struck Feb. 11, and its aftermath.
Judges said: “Videos and photo galleries helped tell the story of the storm as it unfolded with tours of damaged shops, interviews with residents and scenes from the American’s coverage area.
Print coverage the day after the storm moved to recovery efforts and the impact on recreation facilities. A Thursday print story provided a lighter look on how a florist shop was dealing with the damage on possibly the biggest sale day of the year, Valentine’s Day.”
The Marion Star
Nick Bechtel and Kurt Moore, reporters; Holly Fackler, online editor; Bill Sinden, photographer
For coverage of a fire in Harpster that killed three people.
Judges said: “Tweets kept readers informed moment by moment as firefighters arrived. ‘Several fire companies in Harpster.’ ‘Hetzel says 2 apartments affected by the fire that started around 2:56 a.m.’ ‘Spoke w/Sheriff Hetzel. Three people unaccounted for in Wyandot Co. blaze.’
But it wasn’t just text items, staff posted photos to Twitter as well and then built an online gallery.
In print, the identities of those killed were revealed and stories of those who escaped were told. Plus, information on a fund set up to help the victims was included.”
Content Programming: Planned Content
Division I
First Place
The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Richard Ruelas, senior reporter; Pat Shannahan, photographer/videographer
For Richard Ruelas and Pat Shannahan’s extensive reporting on the story of Bill Macumber, a man who, after spending half his life in prison, is freed when a judge finds merit in throwing out his conviction. Macumber’s story is told in multiple installments with a video documentary, tablet-specific features, and selected publishing schedule for different platforms. An event following the series allowed readers to speak with the reporters as well as Macumber himself.
Judges said: “It was clear the journalists began with weighing the best presentation possible for aspects of the story before word one was written. Publishing the entire series on the tablet platform showed consideration of the habits of that audience as well as enticement to view the accompanying video features. The depth and range of the package provided a fascinating view of the subject.”
Finalists
Detroit Free Press
Staff
For Detroit’s massive and well-planned coverage of the North American International Auto Show. The team thought about every audience, every platform and how to play the content throughout the day. The mornings started with breaking news on Freep.com then evolved into longer pieces and wrap ups toward the end of the day. Smartphone and tablet coverage was equally tailored. Print stories focused on thematic enterprise in advance of the formal unveilings.
Judges said: “Detroit thoughtfully planned each piece of coverage for the audience and platform. Then, they delivered quality content – text, photo, social, video – to support the plan. The result: They owned this event. They delivered for each audience. They set a standard for multi-platform event coverage.”
The Des Moines Register
Rick Brown, sports reporter; Rodney White, video/photo; Chad Leistikow, sports editor; Gary Lake, digital sports editor; Bryce Miller, sports columnist; Mark Marturello, illustrator
For an emotional look back at the death of an iconic Iowa sports figure on the 20th anniversary of the accident that took his life. The package included strong storytelling, compelling multimedia and the clear and effective digital presentation.
Judges said: “Des Moines clearly thought about each part of this package, and when and how to best present it. But what set this apart was the emotional connection throughout. The storytelling, videos, photos and design all connected with the community and the feelings it shares about this tragedy.”
Division II
First Place
Poughkeepsie Journal
Barbara Gallo Farrell, Enjoy!/assistant local editor; Emily Stewart, food and drink reporter; Dugan Radwin, niche content coordinator; John Nelson, editor
For thoughtful, strategic coverage of the “Great Tastes” passion topic. Staffers interviewed key audiences to better understand their food coverage needs and media rhythms. The result: Finely tailored content by platform, time of day and day of week that included robust print sections, conversational social media, videos that provide content and promotion, and a sophisticated digital presentation.
Judges said: “Poughkeepsie really thought this out. Locals are passionate about cooking, dining out and nutrition. The team delivered engaging stories, photos and videos in ways that respect the readers’ time, needs and habits.”
Finalists
Argus Leader at Sioux Falls
David Montgomery and Jonathan Ellis, reporters
For David Montgomery and Jonathan Ellis’s coverage of South Dakota senior Sen. Tim Johnson’s decision whether to run for re-election or retire. Background and interviews conducted in anticipation of the announcement freed them to cover the event using a live interactive chat.
Judges said: “The foundation work completed by reporters demonstrates how resources can be realigned for different coverage techniques when not forced to catch up with a story when details break. This was shown to be a benefit to readers on all platforms.”
Pensacola News Journal
Staff
For Pensacola staff’s planned local Mardi Gras coverage, an event that resonates with target audiences who hold an appreciation for tradition and history, the staff crafted a niche site to display the live and historical, biographical, and associated content.
Judges said: “Event coverage can turn stale but Pensacola displayed a considered approach to both pre and post event content and unique presentation in both print and digital platforms.”
Division III
First Place
The Leaf-Chronicle at Clarksville
Greg Williamson, photojournalist
For Greg Williamson’s dispatches from Afghanistan while embedded with the 101st Airborne Division. His stories, photos, videos and Twitter updates gave readers a personal look into the soldiers’ experience. Before leaving, the Leaf-Chronicle collected 700 letters from home for Williamson to deliver to the troops.
Judges said: “Williamson excelled in each area. The writing, the visuals and the social conversation all were equally strong. Williamson showed us the sense of duty as the soldiers prepared to leave, smiles as they opened their letters from home, and the intense bravery when the patrol hit an IED. Great multimedia journalism.”
Finalists
Home News Tribune at East Brunswick
Greg Tufaro and Harry Frezza, staff writers
For multiplatform coverage of the NJSIAA Individual Wrestling Tournament Championships. East Brunswick staffers planned and produced an impressive array of stories, photos, videos and live blog updates throughout the three-day tournament.
Judges said: “The team clearly thought through this coverage, providing just what readers would want. The live blogging was immediate. Photo galleries brought home the excitement. Videos were used to preview and cover the matches. The newspaper stories wrapped up the previous day, set the stage for the day to come and boldly promoted the deeper digital content.”
The Advocate at Newark
Staff
For Newark Advocate entertainment staff’s revised focus on local food and entertainment stories relevant to their “Newark Proud Lifers” audience. Staff turned away from previous coverage strategies for one which included increased coverage of local businesses and topics close to the hearts of their target audience.
Judges said: “Newark staff clearly defined the desires of their audience and keyed on topics which drove social media engagement and fed content plans. This was a solid example of well executed planned content.”
Narrative Writing/Voice
Division I
First Place
The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Scott Craven, senior reporter
For a richly detailed and wonderfully suspenseful story about a brave teenage boy who stepped in front of a bullet to save his younger sister, and a brave father who summoned the courage to forgive his son’s killer.
Judges said: “The ability of Scott Craven to earn the trust of this family was remarkable. In doing so, he was able to reveal a powerful story of tragic loss as well as surprising gain. He moves the story along with expert pacing and compelling quotes, all the while building suspense and holding the reader to the very end. This is the sort of high-quality narrative writing that keeps newspapers relevant.”
Finalists
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Sean Dobbin, reporter
For a story that took readers inside the thoughts, feelings, moral debates and aspirations of heart patients playing the hand life dealt them and also took readers inside the inner workings of their own hearts.
Judges said: “Sean Dobbin’s story about heart patients at Strong Memorial Hospital waiting for others to die so they can live stood out for its intelligent use of the card game as a metaphor for playing the hand that life deals you. The way Dobbin developed each character and laced throughout their stories the science and history of the human heart made for an informative and entertaining read on a subject so important to so many of us.”
Detroit Free Press
John Carlisle, city desk
For a number of stories that quickly envelop readers into the small details of a husband searching for his missing wife, a family besieged by a rapist/arsonist and of a neighborhood rocked by an exploded home. Those small details are the ones that make the stories, and its characters, become intimate friends of the readers.
Judges said: “John Carlisle has an uncanny ability to take his readers to the scene of his stories in clear, quick language packed with emotion. His piece “Young Hero” tells the story of a mid-Michigan teen taking in a rape victim and protecting her and his siblings as the attacker pounds at the front door. That story, along with “It’s like a war zone,” about an exploded home in Detroit, and “I just want her back home,” about a husband looking for his missing wife, make his readers feel in a few moments like they’ve known his subjects their whole life, and you feel for them in their struggles.”
Division II
First Place
The Clarion-Ledger at Jackson, Miss.
Emily LeCoz, investigative reporter
For a thoroughly reported, masterfully crafted narrative of a major doping scandal that causes her readers to second-guess their assumptions and think critically about the news.
Judges said: “As journalists, we are called to challenge our readers’ assumptions, encourage them to think critically and differently about what may have been a foregone conclusion in their minds. Emily LeCoz’ ‘The Tragic Tale of Tammy Thomas’ does just that, by introducing us fully to Thomas the budding young athlete moving into a world of high-stakes athletics, we begin to question who’s really to blame for her actions. When our friends make bad choices, we all debate whether to condemn them or give them the benefit of the doubt because we know them, and LeCoz’ work makes Thomas that wayward friend for her readers.”
Finalists
Asheville Citizen-Times
Barbara Blake, staff writer
For an enlightening profile of a man and his ministry work with those on the outer-edge of his community.
Judges said: “Barbara Blake’s tight and punchy writing made this a delightful read. Her work was nearly as extraordinary as the subject of her story whom she introduced to readers on a highly personal level.”
Argus Leader at Sioux Falls
Steve Young, reporter
For a thorough and emotional series of stories examining the dark subject of suicide and its impact on surviving family members.
Judges said: “Steve Young’s collection of heart-breaking tales of families coping with the suicides of loved ones broke through the stigma with honest and raw emotion as well as helpful explanation and great context. Kudos to him for taking on this taboo subject and delivering fine analysis and storytelling.”
Division III
First Place
The Daily Advertiser at Lafayette, La.
Bill Decker, metro editor
An enlightening look at a piece of Colfax history that was – perhaps deliberately – left out of the institutional memory of the community.
Judges said: “One of a journalist’s most important jobs is to be the first author of history, but sometimes that job comes a century after history was made. In his piece, ‘The sign at Colfax,’ Bill Decker tells in detail the other side of a story not included on a historical marker townspeople pass by daily. Through his piece, Decker reminds his readers that one man’s ‘riot’ is another man’s ‘massacre,’ and reminds his community of the important role they played in the history of American civil rights.”
Finalist
The Jackson Sun at Jackson, Tenn.
Jordan Buie, reporter
For a selection of features about life in Benton County, Tenn., ranging from the aftermath of a wind storm to remembrances of an infamous plane crash.
Judges said: “Jordan Buie showed the importance of conveying sense of place. Also, these were people stories at their roots, and he demonstrated a clear understanding of the people he is writing about and for. Great detail and strong anecdotes made these enjoyable to read.”
Finalists
Iowa City Press-Citizen
Josh O’Leary, reporter
For a selection of harder-news explanatory stories about community development and university projects in Iowa City.
Judges said: “The degree of difficulty on these topics was high, but Josh O’Leary turned what could have been clutter into easily understandable storytelling. O’Leary craftily weaved together descriptions of the projects and the people behind the work. This was important information for readers, and he made sure they understood it.”
Short Form Writing/Voice
Division I
First Place
Detroit Free Press
Jim Schaefer, staff writer; Tresa Baldas, staff writer; Michele Siuda, web editor; Stefanie Murray, assistant managing editor/digital
For Jim Schaefer, Tresa Baldas, Michele Siuda and Stefanie Murray and their use of short-form writing/voice in covering the Kwame Kilpatrick trial.
Judges said: “Whether it was on the blog done mostly from the courthouse or tweets, Jim Schaefer maintained consistency and personality in his tweets and keeping people informed.
As an example, here’s one from day 13 of deliberations: ‘Yep, that’s right. I’ve foregone the trip down to the courthouse today. I figure maybe switching things up will jar something loose. Agree?’
And here’s one from Twitter: ‘Day 13, not a peep from the #KwameKilpatrick jury. Come vent at noon EST…’ with a link to the live blog.
And, of course, from the Freep’s own Twitter account the end: ‘Kwame #Kilpatrick found guilty of racketeering conspiracy, extortion…’ with a link to the story.
The blog attracted 4,000 to 18,000 daily visitors and many engaged, asking questions, offering opinions etc.
When Jim wasn’t around, the digital staffers filled in and reporter Tresa Baldas provided details for Jim to relay to followers.”
Finalists
The News-Press at Fort Myers
Staff
For coverage of the Florida Gulf Coast University Eagles NCAA Cinderella story on Twitter.
Judges said: “From the games, a bus on the way to the games with students or the communities they were in, the staff shared the experience with readers in short bursts, injecting bits of personality along the way. Seth Soffian brought readers this gem: “Otto Porter just made a face that said it all. ‘Damn. We are in trouble. These guys are for real.’ Approximately speaking #FGCU.” And, he engaged with fans, answering their questions and even letting them in to his personal life – slightly – with a tweet about him buying clothes at a thrift store.
Carl Bleich kept people on top of key plays and scores well, but also injected this: “Tell me somebody is DVRing this game for me. I gotta watch it when I get home.”
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Jeff DiVeronica, sports reporter
For Jeff DiVeronica’s tweets about Syracuse’s NCAA trip March 27-29.
Judges said: “Jeff DiVeronica’s voice and personality came through whether he was posting photos or facts about the game. But, he also brought some behind-the-scenes, amusing things to light including this post: “Yes, these signs exist. And you thought the government watches you closely. #NCAA” with a link to a picture about how only NCAA cups were allowed past a certain point.”
Division II
First Place
Courier-Post at Cherry Hill
Mike Youngkin, digital producer
For Mike Youngkin’s excellent use of short, catchy statements and teasers on Facebook and Twitter to draw people to Courier-Post content.
Judges said: “Mike Youngkin’s posts made me laugh and want to read content that I had no idea I wanted to read.
Whether it’s about beer and your lawn such as this one from Facebook, ‘Having a beer may make everyone at the bar prettier, but can it do the same for your lawn?’ or this golf-related post, ‘Holes on a golf course are expected. Golfer-swallowing sinkholes on the 14th green are not.’ He injects humor and personality in each post.
His posts read like a snarky friend at times … and in these instances it worked.”
Finalists
The Clarion-Ledger at Jackson, Miss.
Marshall Ramsey, editorial cartoonist
For Marshall Ramsey’s consistent use of short, engaging and often humorous tweets on a variety of topics.
Judges said: “Marshall Ramsey uses Twitter to reach a new audience and does it well, maintaining his voice regardless of topic.
Take this one on the asteroid that was approaching Earth: ‘Giant asteroid will miss Earth by 15 minutes. Good thing. Our shuttles are retired and Bruce Willis is off promoting a new movie.’
Then there was this one: ‘Dear God, thank you for allowing me to live in a state where people steal monkeys and try to ransom them. Signed a cartoonist.’
His posts inject fun into his more than 13,000 followers’ day
The Greenville News.”
Staff
For the Greenville News staff’s consistent voice regardless of who is manning the Twitter reins.
Judges said: “The Greenville team set a goal to be smart, quick and humorous on Twitter and that’s been achieved.
They tell people the news, without hitting them with a newspaper headline. For a story/photo about a cop car that overturned in a chase, followers saw this, ‘An upstate cop car wound up like this after a truck turned in front of it.’
Or, for a story about the weather on Easter: ‘Grab a sweater, #Easter Bunny. Cold, windy weather still stinging upstate.'”
Division III
First Place
Courier News at Bridgewater
Sergio Bichao, staff reporter
For Sergio Bichao’s coverage of Amy Locane’s trial in the drunk-driving death of local woman on Twitter.
Judges said: “Sergio Bichao’s concise tweets on the trial conveyed information to readers clearly and told the story, linking to stories, photos and videos.
During the sentencing, Bichao tweeted this: ‘Son, husband, mom of Helene Seeman say Amy Locane shows no remorse, takes no responsibility.’
While most tweets were very straight-forward, Bichao injected human voice when appropriate, such as this one: ‘Tough video: This husband lost his high-school sweetheart to a drunk driver. This son lost his mother.'”
Finalist
The News-Star at Monroe
Barbara Leader, senior writer
For Barbara Leader’s round-by-round tweets from the All-Parish Spelling Bee.
Judges said: “Barbara Leader stayed on top of the action minute-by-minute, as children competed for the top prize in the All-Parish Spelling Bee. From round 1 to the end, she kept readers informed with very concise posts. Yet, she managed to add personality to them as well.
She told readers what the words were in each round. ‘Ingenious, panzer and behoove tripped up spellers in round 2 of the #All Parish Spelling Bee. 25 spellers remain,’ she tweeted. Then, there was, ‘Chimichanga claimed one victim. 2 advance #All Parish Spelling Bee.'”
Photojournalism
Division I
First Place
The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Nick Oza, photographer/videographer
For a craftfully photographed inside look at an ancient Hindu ritual.
Judges said: “Photojournalist Nick Oza delivered stunningly beautiful and storytelling imagery of the Kumbh Mela, a mass pilgrimage to India for devout Hindus. Oza took full advantage of his inside access to capture intimate moments of the various aspects of the ceremony. The picture through a sari drying on the ground epitomized Nick’s eye for a great shot.”
Finalists
The Journal News at Westchester
Carucha L. Meuse, visual journalist
For a series of photos capturing the construction of a subway tunnel, Grand Central Terminal and championship basketball.
Judges said: “Carucha Meuse provided an excellent sense of place and scale with the pictures of Grand Central Terminal and subway construction. The photos of the terminal gave a great feel for what life is like inside the hub and the subway shots revealed just how big, and dirty, the job of building a tunnel is. Overall, the shots were simply stunning and made readers feel as if they were there.”
Detroit Free Press
Ryan Garza, staff photographer
For a collection of photographs detailing the story of a Holocaust survivor, an auto show and a profile of a restaurant.
Judges said: “Photographer Ryan Garza perfectly captured the emotions of his assignments. His shot of a Holocaust survivor paired with pictures of his children demonstrates the resilience, and even defiance for a man who faced death. The picture of the couple goofing around at the auto show presents great enjoyment, especially because it is paired with the obviously perturbed older gentleman wondering what those kids are doing.”
Division II
First Place
Courier-Post at Cherry Hill
Jose Moreno, photographer
For a portraits series blended with music and narration from photographer Jose Moreno.
Judges said: “The portraits from photographer Jose Moreno provide a compelling look at several area residents. While simple, the shots are compelling and enhanced by Moreno’s narrative description about the power of a picture. Plus, he explains, it gives us the freedom to stare. Overall a great package.”
Finalists
Pensacola News Journal
Ben Twingley, photographer
For a solid collection of breaking news and general news images that capture the key moments of multiple events.
Judges said: “Ben Twingley’s image of an umpire getting taken to the ground during a bench clearing brawl is outstanding. The collection of images captures the complete reporting of the tournament all the way through the investigation by police after the game.
Twigley’s other package of images on the docking of the Carnival Triumph’s docking in Mobile was timely. He captured the emotion of the passengers as they disembarked after several days at sea.”
The Post-Crescent at Appleton
Dan Powers, photographer
For a photo blog detailing the end of the Packers season and the end of Donald Driver’s career.
Judges said: “Dan Powers masterfully packages an additional selection of game day images into a photo-blog that speaks to Appleton’s core audience. The combination of photos and explanations make the ensemble truly enjoyable.”
Division III
First Place
Palladium-Item at Richmond
Joshua Smith, photographer
For pictures depicting a student being comforted at a memorial service and a coach reacting to an official’s late-game call.
Judges said: “Photographer Joshua Smith showed an eye for capturing the moment in finding a student being comforted among a crowd of her peers. In the basketball game, he perfectly caught the ire of a coach, the disbelief of the assistant and framed it well enough to include background reaction from several fans.
Overall, his ability to capture, and thus stir, emotions from his work was why it should be honored.”
Finalists
The News Leader at Staunton
Katie Currid, photojournalist
The work over multiple galleries shows the photographer’s versatility and her ability to find relevant storytelling images.
Judges said: “Katie Curid brought a variety of topics to life for the readers in her community. Everything from an introduction of several new young artists to a fox hunt to a look inside the Virginia Women’s Institute for Leadership. Curid captured individuals’ personalities by masterfully using the elements in their surroundings to add additional layers of information. Curid also used a keen eye to photograph interesting and relevant details from each topic area.”
The Jackson Sun at Jackson, Tenn.
Kenneth Cummings, photographer
For extensive work chronicling high school sports through the state basketball tournament.
Judges said: “Photographer Kenneth Cummings showed a knack for finding excellent action and emotion throughout numerous basketball photographs. Putting so much focus on a passion topic seemed to pay dividends for the paper for how well the work was received.”
Video Journalism
Division I
First Place
Gannett Government Media
Colin Kelly, senior video journalist
For a video detailing a veteran’s unique memorial to those fallen in Afghanistan.
Judges said: “Colin Kelly provided a masterful video showing one of the most fascinating tributes to fallen soldiers. The use of multiple shots, angles and interviews was captivating for viewers and told the story in a way print could never do alone. It was truly an excellent piece of journalism that was a joy to watch.”
Finalists
Detroit Free Press
Zlati Meyer, staff writer; Jarrad Henderson, staff photographer; Mandi Wright, staff photographer; Romain Blanquart, staff photographer
For a not-so-serious approach to everyday storytelling in and around Detroit.
Judges said: “Reporter Zlati Meyer has an entertaining and fun approach to covering what may be otherwise considered mundane assignments. Her interviews at the auto show were engaging and funny. She and the videographers that work with her have definitely found a niche.”
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Mike Nyerges, graphics journalist
For a video describing heroin addiction and one describing Rep. John Boehner’s conservative credentials.
Judges said: “Mike Nyerges perfectly blends graphics, music and interviews to tell the story of heroin addiction in southeastern Ohio. The video gives us not only the personal story of the drug, but also how widespread it has become. The Boehner video also uses unique elements to answer a question many in the political circles had asked as the Speaker faced another vote for his gavel.”
Division II
First Place
Reno Gazette-Journal
Liz Margerum, videographer
For a comparison of two local schools on opposite ends of the district’s proficiency rating.
Judges said: “Videographer Liz Margerum took an interesting and engaging approach to compare two schools with vastly different proficiency scores, even if parents of both expressed similar goals and desires. The reporting was thorough and the videography was outstanding. This piece was executed and edited better than any of its competition.”
Finalists
The Burlington Free Press
Staff
For five videos showing a range of different events and places in Vermont.
Judges said: “The five videos by the Burlington staff were nothing if not entertaining. Each brought the viewer into the moment, provided a smile if not a laugh and generally left us happier after watching. The videos were also well edited, high quality and told the story without dragging on.”
Press & Sun-Bulletin at Binghamton
Kristopher Radder, staff photographer
For a video on an Iraq war veteran trying to return to normalcy after being severely injured by a roadside bomb in 2006.
Judges said: “Kristopher Radder gives viewers an intense, complete tale of a war veteran who has lost much, including his face. His story, while uplifting, also forced viewers to confront directly the disturbing reality facing those injured in combat.”
Division III
First Place
Herald Times Reporter at Manitowoc
Ben Wideman, features editor; Sarah Kloepping, videographer
For a series of six videos describing the life and stories of Eastern Catholic monks in St. Nazianz.
Judges said: “Videographer Sarah Kloepping and editor Ben Wideman took us inside an Eastern Catholic monastery, giving a glimpse of a life most have never seen. The videos were of high technical quality, well edited and provided a complete story of the monks’ lives. They were both informational and enjoyable to view.”
Finalists
Courier News at Bridgewater
Sergio Bichao, staff reporter; Kathy Johnson and Jason Towlen, staff photographers
A comprehensive overview of the trial of actress Amy Locane who was convicted of manslaughter in a drunk driving case.
Judges said: “The Bridgewater team did an excellent job of explaining what was expected during the sentencing phase of actress Amy Locane in a brief overview video. Then the team captured the raw emotion from inside the courtroom as family members of the woman who was killed address the court and as Locane herself broke down while addressing the family members. They brought the trial to life for their readers.”
Chillicothe Gazette
Brent Lewis, visual journalist
This entry provided two strong examples of alternative ways to approach video storytelling by using time lapse for a room remodel and pairing mug shots with a past drug addict’s story.
Judges said: “I loved the way Brent Lewis used a time-lapse camera to capture all of the frantic work as they remodeled a bedroom for a local family. The technique helped illustrate a process that is not easily shown in one photo or in a single short video.
Additionally, the use of arrest mug shots from one individual who has struggled with addiction to illustrate the physical effects of drug use was powerful. A good use of a technique along with the underlying interview to clearly explain a topic to their readers.”
Design
Division I
First Place
The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Rachel Orr and Chris Ballard of the Phoenix Design Studio; Andrea Heser, Adrienne Hapanowicz and Bill Pliske of Republic Media
For offering fans of the cactus league a multiplatform presentation that was rich in information and sophistication.
Judges said: “The Republic and Phoenix Design Studio delivered Cactus League fans a comprehensive print and digital presentation that was simply overflowing with great material.
The AZ Today Cactus League edition made you want to play. Yes, it had the previews of each team, schedules and a map of the stadiums. But, it also had scrollable, panoramic views of the stadiums, high-resolution photos you could scroll in to see a flung baseball’s stitches in mid-flight, the bubble a player was blowing on the field and more.
The app also featured a fan’s dream – the chance to go behind-the-scenes at media day with the Arizona Diamondbacks via a time-lapse video. Plus, extra stats, team mascots and dining options near each stadium.”
App available for download.
Finalists
Asbury Park Press
Jennifer Meyer, designer
For Jennifer Meyer’s design work for table, Asbury Park’s food section. A diverse assortment of presentations ranging from typographic to infographic to illustrative and photo-driven.
Judges said: “Each of the designer’s presentations demonstrates a clear understanding of the subject matter and showcases table’s ability to reinvent itself from week to week to cater to the cover story. Details are executed flawlessly – nothing is overdone and each decision made elevates the design and allows for specific entry points into the story. Very smart, clean, well-thought-out work in all cases.”
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Sean Dobbin, reporter; Annette Lein, photographer; Nestor Ramos, exclusive enterprise editor; Leah Balconi, designer
For Rochester’s compelling, “The Seven of Hearts” iPad app.
Judges said: “This team put together a package designed specifically to capture what an iPad could do – without interfering with the narrative storytelling of seven men awaiting heart transplants at Strong Memorial Hospital who play poker once a week.
It flowed like a movie, carrying the user along – encouraging clicks on poker chips to reveal more photos, on cards to reveal a saying or to watch a video.
Sidebars were highlighted with an image and a gray background.
Through it all, the Poker theme was carried out using cards to mark page numbers and a black club icon to indicate how to get to the next page.”
The Courier-Journal at Louisville
Louisville Design Studio staff
For coverage of the University of Louisville throughout the NCAA basketball tournament. Story lines covered the full spectrum from previewing the start of the tournament to live game coverage and analysis.
Judges said: “The Louisville Design Studio staff rose to the occasion to allow each day’s design to adapt to the news of the day. Their coverage had an immediate impact thanks to the creative twist on the tournament seedings, done as only Louisville can, as silks. Their work remained at a high level throughout the tournament, showcasing strong photography, offering readers clean, easy-to-read stats and team comparisons, as well as showy section fronts and poster pages any UL fan would be proud to hang on their wall. A championship performance.”
Division II
First Place
Poughkeepsie Journal
Michael Grant, Asbury Park Design Studio; Mike Benischek, sports editor and Dan Pietrafesa, sports writer, Poughkeepsie Journal
For exceptional design work on the Players recreational sports section.
Judges said: “The team put together an exceptional Players section, especially the ‘Tour De Spain’ page.
The designs showed strong typography and clean, bold presentations that showcase the varied content and good use of color. Bio boxes and other items provided numerous entry points.”
Finalists
Montgomery Advertiser
Montgomery Advertiser sports/copy desk and Nashville Design Studio staff
For work on the Alabama Crimson Tide’s BCS national title section.
Judges said: “This was a noble effort to cover a late-breaking game and produce a comprehensive section that captures the excitement of the win and the Tide’s domination of Notre Dame.
With a limited window of time, the staff did a lot. The pre-planning was evident.
The team produced memorable/keepsake covers for 1A and the section front.”
Argus Leader at Sioux Falls
Karla Brown-Garcia, Heartland Team Leader, Des Moines Design Studio
For Karla Brown-Garcia, Des Moines Design Studio and the Heartland Team Leader’s four-page pull-off section, “Does rural America still matter?”
Judges said: “The smart use of a gorgeous photograph to produce a landscape wrap gave the reader a surprise upon opening up the section cover. Graphics inside added context and depth to the presentation.”
Division III
First Place
The Sheboygan Press
Sean McKeown-Young, Wisconsin Design Team Leader, Des Moines Design Studio
For Sean McKeown-Young of the Des Moines Design Studio and his Sunday A1 presentations for The Sheboygan Press. Sean used original illustrations to showcase the impact of cyber-bullying at local schools as well as a look at a growing trend of women seeking out gun training for both sport and protection.
Judges said: “Sean’s bold A1 illustrations clearly captivate your attention and immediately capture the essence of the subject matter. He shows tremendous creativity in his presentations: The choice of Rosie the Riveter to represent not only women but the idea of women becoming more independent in entering an otherwise male-dominated segment of the world was a smart, appropriate use of symbolism. Attention to detail was evident as well, from the NRA emblem adorning Rosie’s blouse or the “HATE UGLY STUPID” language filling the computer screen as the hand of the cyber bully literally “@ttacks” the reader. ”
Finalists
The Daily News Journal at Murfreesboro
Merry Eccles, designer, Nashville Design Studio
For Merry Eccles’ use of scripture text in the form of Jesus to celebrate the religious significance of Easter Sunday for readers of The Daily News Journal in Murfreesboro, Tenn.
Judges said: “The designer captured the holy significance of the day through a calculated use of dark and light scripture text to allow the face of Jesus to come to the forefront of readers’ attention on Easter Sunday. Her restraint in competing elements on the page – from a clean headline presentation to pulling back on The Daily News Journal nameplate – was evident and allowed the simplicity, beauty and meaning behind the illustration to stand uninterrupted.”
Iowa City Press-Citizen
Liv Anderson, Erin Baker Crabb and Hillory Stirler, designers, Des Moines Design Studio
For Des Moines Design Studio efforts in establishing a strong series of page designs and custom illustrations to showcase the unique stories of everyday Johnson County residents for the Iowa City Press-Citizen.
Judges said: “The designer successfully married a combination of engaging documentary photographs with her own original illustrations and clean design flourishes to carry a playful and engaging theme throughout this special section. Her solid framework for the page designs flowed with ease across single pages, two-page spreads and even ad stack pages to keep the focus on the unique stories within.”