Press Releases

For immediate release

Springfield Takes “Best in Show” in the Third-Quarter Awards of Excellence

The third-quarter Awards of Excellence contest showed that Gannett journalists continue to find new and creative ways to be strong, purposeful voices in the communities we serve.

The Springfield News-Leader led the way in this regard. Their potent documenting of child poverty in the Ozarks was so dominant — it was the superior entry in the Public Service, Outstanding Writing, Visual/Design and Multimedia storytelling categories — that judges decided to create a special award: Best in Show.

The Journal News at Westchester and the Statesman Journal at Salem both impressed judges with sophisticated digital techniques that helped readers delve deep into watchdog reports that connected to passion topics. Both Westchester’s and Salem’s work were examples of the dynamic, platform-perfect new storytelling methods that distinguish us from competitors.

Hurricane Isaac was one of the biggest news stories of the quarter. It affected more than a dozen of our sites in the South. The Clarion-Ledger at Jackson, Miss., and The News Star at Monroe impressed judges the most, not just with their coverage of the storm’s hit but also with their focus on clear, practical content that helped readers prepare. Across all our sites in the South, the Isaac coverage was made deeper and more meaningful through two new cooperative efforts:
㄀㄀㄀- WXIA-TV in Atlanta provided hourly, customized weather report videos for our sites in Florida,
㄀㄀㄀㄀㄀Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana as the hurricane bore down and made its way through the
㄀㄀㄀㄀㄀region.
㄀㄀㄀- An ad-hoc team of social media producers from TV stations and newspaper sites around the
㄀㄀㄀㄀㄀country (but not in Isaac’s path) used Spredfast to monitor and deliver relevant social content to
㄀㄀㄀㄀㄀affected sites. The team worked 24/7 for more than a week, proving that a decentralized team of
㄀㄀㄀㄀㄀journalists with a clearly defined mission can be a force-multiplier in the coverage we offer
㄀㄀㄀㄀㄀readers.

Forty-six local news organizations, one regional consortium and five design studios earned citations this quarter. After Springfield, top-performing sites were:
㄀㄀㄀- Division I: Detroit (6); Phoenix and Wilmington (4 each)
㄀㄀㄀- Division II: Burlington (5); Salem (4) and Poughkeepsie (3)
㄀㄀㄀- Division III: Monroe and Staunton (3 each); Elmira (2)
㄀㄀㄀- Design studios: Des Moines (3); Asbury Park (2)

Judges

Judges for the third quarter were: Carolyn Washburn, vice president/content and audience development, The Cincinnati Enquirer; Mike Knuth, executive editor, Green Bay Press-Gazette; Mike Townsend, executive editor, The Burlington Free Press; Kelly Scott, breaking news editor, Reno Gazette-Journal; Nhia Yang, general manager/executive editor, Herald Times Reporter of Manitowoc and The Sheboygan Press; Erin Brethauer, multimedia editor, Asheville Citizen-Times.

Best in Show
Springfield News-Leader
Claudette Riley, reporter; Valerie Mosley, photographer; Cheryl Whitsitt, managing editor; Dean Curtis, multimedia editor; Matt Peterson, assistant managing editor; Karla Brown Garcia, Team Leader, Des Moines Design Studio

A note on this unique award

As mentioned above, judges decided to create the Best in Show award to honor Springfield for its work on child poverty in the Ozarks.

No such award has ever been part of the Awards of Excellence. But as judges weighed the Springfield News Leader’s entry of this content in four categories – each of which highlighted very different aspects of the coverage – they felt compelled to add this special citation, out of fairness to both Springfield and the other competitors in the four categories.

As a result, three other news organizations earned first-place honors (Salem won two of the categories), four were named finalists and Springfield’s work was elevated to Best in Show.

Category winners normally earn $250 prizes, which will be paid to Salem ($500 for two wins), Burlington and Great Falls. If Springfield had won all four categories, it would have been in line for $1,000. But because their work was so good as to warrant a new one-time category, the USCP news team decided $2,000 was more appropriate.

Judges’ comments about Springfield’s work:

For an extensive series focused on children and families struggling in Springfield. The work shined a light on those living in poverty through stories, photos and multimedia components.

In the Public Service category, judges said: “The most impressive entry in all the categories reviewed for the third quarter. The whole Springfield team should take a bow. The stories pull you in and won’t let go. The photography is excellent. The presentation is outstanding. The online conversation with the community was a great addition to this piece. The ‘Want to Help’ info box with each day’s story was an important addition to this series, which moved the community to help those in need. Riley did a remarkable job of setting the scene and bringing the reader into the desperate lives of people living below the poverty line. Mosley’s images are striking, and bring the reader to a place you wish did not exist. Clearly, the organization and editing of this series was a huge undertaking, and Whitsitt deserves credit for putting the pieces together. The journalism, courage and leadership embodied in this series should make every staff member in Springfield proud to say, ‘I work at the News-Leader.’

In the Outstanding Writing category, judges said: “Riley told the story of child poverty through the experiences of several families. That is not so unexpected. But the structure of the project was unusual and moving; each day had a theme through which she told the children’s stories — no home, no shoes, no food, no car, no peace. Sentence structures were simple, getting out of the way of the devastating specific examples she used. Quotes were never redundant, and Riley used them to take me inside her subjects’ hearts and minds rather than to describe things that happened. She uses chronology in her anecdotes to make those situations feel more live. We wanted to read every word.”

In the Visual Journalism: Design category, judges said: “The design presentation for this special series online and in print is thematic and powerful, highlighting the importance of the topic, the urgency of the need to help and the faces of those in need. The emphasis is on people in print and online. The design online cohesive with online, creating a complimentary and contextual design. Well done.”

In the Multimedia Storytelling category, judges said: “The visuals were exceptional. A sense of hopelessness pervades the images. The image of a refrigerator with but six items is a memory that stays with you. Searing. Soul-searching. Powerful.”

Watchdog Journalism
Division I

First Place

The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
JJ Hensley and Rob O’Dell, reporters; Nick Oza, photographer/videographer; Lynn French, videographer/video editor

For an investigation by JJ Hensley and Rob O’Dell into 400 sex-crime cases the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office reopened. It started with the story of the rape of a 13-year-old, in which the victim’s family said the Sheriff’s Office mishandled the investigation.

Judges said: “Hensley and O’Dell examined 1,500 pages of documents in 400 sex-crime cases that the Maricopa Sheriff’s Office was pressured to reopen. They linked documents with data and created their own database. They revealed shocking lapses in investigations — suspects who were not interviewed, background checks not done. In one case they learned that files on a case were sitting in a drawer in a deputy’s garage. As a result, suspects stayed free and committed additional crimes. The work was smartly presented online, including the searchable database. And the reporter did a TV report to discuss the investigation and impact on victims.”

Finalists

Detroit Free Press
Jennifer Dixon and Jim Schaefer, reporters; Kristi Tanner, reporter and Mandi Wright, photojournalist

For a report that was both serious and a talker about the impact of non-handicapped people parking in handicapped spaces.

Judges said: The topic was original and surprising, yet relatable to virtually everyone. A right-under-your-nose issue. For some it is an annoyance and for others a deadly serious issue. The work took seriously a concern of a vulnerable and growing group of people in the community. The reporting was authoritative, using documents and databases to determine which communities enforce access and which do not. The report also was authoritative — and highly engaging — because the journalists went to the primary sources, the people who park in handicapped spots. They spent time near handicapped parking spaces around the community and talked to people as they parked. They did a very smart video of that experience — smart because it was well-organized and narrated to serve as a complete story in itself. They talked to doctors who have to sign off on handicapped permits. And they talked to people — via print and video — whose lives are disrupted when they can’t get access to handicapped parking spots. It was no laughing matter.

The Des Moines Register
Jason Clayworth, investigative writer

For an evaluation of inspections of school buses and other buses that carry children.

Judges said: It is an issue that is close to home but not something the community had been talking about. Jason reviewed more than 125,000 Iowa school bus inspections over the last five years. He found multiple cases of buses returned to the road without serious problems being fixed. He found that vans and other vehicles that carry children to extra-curricular and athletic activities are not subject to inspection. And that private schools and organizations can simply repaint school buses and they are no longer subject to state inspections. Coverage included a database that allowed readers to search for their school or by types of incidents. As a result of the reporting, the Department of Education is discussing adding more inspectors. And state education officials will ask legislators to require inspections for vehicles used for extra-curricular travel.

The Indianapolis Star
Tim Evans, reporter

For an investigation into a tip that the head of the Department of Child Services got personally involved in a case involving his own son and grandchildren.

Judges said: Tim had a history of authoritative coverage of problems in the Indiana Department of Child Services. Because of that expert work, he received a new tip — that the director of the department was personally involved with a case involving his son and grandchildren and that the director had even slapped one of his grandchildren. Tim made smart use of public records that provided clear evidence of the director’s involvement. When Tim asked the governor for comment, it was the first time the governor learned what was going on. The director resigned the day after the investigation published.

The Journal News at Westchester
David McKay Wilson, tax columnist

For David McKay Wilson’s Tax Watchdog beat, including ongoing beat work and an investigation of overspending in the BOCES school district.
Judges said: When Westchester determined that taxes was a passion topic, it created a Tax Watch team led by Tax Watchdog columnist David McKay Wilson. It includes a page online, a blog, databases, regularly labeled columns in print and in-depth investigations. David, with support from his colleagues, writes about a wide range of tax-related issues across the community. And his bigger investigation found that a superintendent was skirting rules that would have capped her salary and making expensive personal use of a district car. David caught her in a lie when she said she had reimbursed the district for the personal use of the car, causing her to come back and admit she hadn’t. The state education commissioner is calling for action. It is a good example of a hard-news, authoritative, sustained body of work to serve a community passion.

Division II

First Place

Poughkeepsie Journal
Mary Beth Pfeiffer, special projects reporter

For an ongoing investigative report that detailed how the state of New York overbilled the federal government through Medicaid for billions of dollars over the course of two decades.

Judges said: “Reporter Mary Beth Pfieffer did an amazing job of taking years of information, decades of poor government oversight, and pulling it all together for a blockbuster watchdog report on the chronic overpayment of Medicaid reimbursement to New York state. Simply put, this is great journalism. If the lead does not pull you in, you might not have a pulse: “New York state overcharged the federal government $10 billion for care at institutions for the developmentally disabled under a decades-old funding scheme that was first publicly revealed by the Poughkeepsie Journal…”
Like a true watchdog, the Poughkeepsie Journal has chased this story for a long time, and now that it has its teeth into the issue, it won’t let go. This reporting led a congressional committee on oversight and government reform to reference the Poughkeepsie Journal’s ongoing series in a July report.”

Finalists

Gannett Wisconsin Media
Eric Litke, reporter

For a three-part series on the lack of oversight tied to Wisconsin’s booming virtual schools landscape. From performance to attendance, the report detailed the state’s inadequate standards and oversight.

Judges said: “Reporter Eric Litke did a great job digging into the details underneath the virtual school world in Wisconsin, and his reporting exposed real shortcomings and prompted the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction to scramble following his report. The DPI announced it plans to do an in-depth study of performance for virtual school students. Eric’s reporting forced DPI’s hand, and the strong writing and outstanding detail provided in the dozen PDFs that accompanied the piece made it stand out in this competitive category.”

Montgomery Advertiser
Brad Zimanek, sports editor

For an investigative report that exposed a local private school’s football coach was awarding “fake” scholarship letters to athletes from colleges that had no knowledge of the offer or the athletes involved. The report led to a larger investigation, which uncovered other problems with the coach and the program.

Judges said: “It was refreshing to see a strong piece of watchdog work from the world of sports, which too often gets a free pass from our journalists. Brad Zimanek did a nice job talking with players and their families about a program surrounded by fraud and financial irregularities. The state high school athletic association followed up on Brad’s strong reporting by placing the school on probation and retroactively forfeiting all the football team’s victories during the 2011 season. This story impacted a lot of people, and Brad’s strong focus on getting to the bottom of a scandal in a high school football program clearly meant a lot to readers in Montgomery.”

Lansing State Journal
Lindsay VanHulle, reporter

For a revealing piece on the city of East Lansing’s questionable handling of a major downtown construction project that became a topic of conversation in the community after a portion of the building collapsed.

Judges said: “Reporter Lindsay VanHulle’s strong reporting and the timeline appropriately titled “Anatomy of a Collapse” gave readers a wonderful synopsis of a project gone bad. By starting with Freedom of Information requests and detailing the city and the developer’s missteps along the way, Lindsay clearly became an expert on this topic, which benefited the readers of the State Journal. City officials acknowledged their overly friendly approach to development led to this debacle. Without Lindsay’s reporting, city officials would never have owned up to their mistakes and flawed policies.”

Division III

First Place

The News-Star at Monroe
Barbara Leader, writer

For assertive coverage that exposed a deliberate attempt by the state education superintendent to manipulate the public discussion over significant challenges on implementation of a new schools voucher program.

Judges said: “In four stories, Reporter Barbara Leader delivered an example of classic watchdog journalism. She obtained revealing emails sent by the state education superintendent to the governor’s spokesman and also a policy adviser. The emails were a response to coverage by the newspaper concerning an incomplete review of the voucher program. The emails spoke for themselves:

— “Create a news story” to prop up due diligence for the review.”
— “Take some air out of the story.”
— “Give (Rep.) Steve (Carter) some cover.”
— “Kill multiple birds with one stone.”
— “Talk … with media, muddy up the narrative they’re trying to keep black and white.”

Leader found the string and kept pulling. The reporter provided readers with a rounded definition of “due diligence” at the highest levels of state government. A state legislator translated the meaning of black and white: “high-grade deception.”

Finalists

Pacific Daily News at Guam
Steve Limtiaco, projects and data editor

For a well-reported accountability story about candidates for elective office who over the years have had encounters with the criminal justice system. By law, these encounters must be vetted by the Guam Election Commission to determine fitness for office. After the story ran, one candidate for a mayor’s job dropped from the race.

Judges said: “Reporter Steve Limtiaco provides an interesting story on the public records trail that can follow anyone even into elective office. Misdemeanors or criminal charges include fines for reckless driving, disorderly conduct, and battery, disturbing the peace, assault, charges of sexual assault and charges of conspiracy to commit theft. He unearthed one federal case of theft missed by the Guam Election Commission that led to the mayoral candidate dropping out of the election. Limtiaco provides context in all situations and repeatedly seeks out comments from candidates. The voter is left to decide the value of this information. “

Times Herald at Port Huron
Holly Setter, reporter

For a single convincing story that showed how abuse of prescription drugs was a growing threat in the community.

Judges said: “Reporter Holly Setter wrote an enticing lead, told what the story means to readers, built the story based on hard numbers, relied on expert sources to build authoritative reporting, interviewed grassroots sources to make the impact of the abuse real, delved into the question of accountability and ended with a quest for solutions. The story was well written and cohesive.”

Public Service Journalism
Division I

First Place

The News Journal at Wilmington
Jeff Montgomery and Molly Murray, staff writers; Dan Garrow, graphic artist; Gary Emeigh, staff photographer; Patrick Sweet, data analyst

For The News Journal special report about the impact and future implications of climate change along the Mid-Atlantic.

Judges said: “Some people doubt climate change, but The News Journal provided ample evidence that change is happening along the coast that will profoundly challenge communities to make hard decisions about their futures. The report was comprehensive, looking not only at Delaware but also Maryland and Virginia. It connected data and extensive personal accounts. The volume of personal examples was important to giving the report its authority. Graphics were an important storytelling tool. Videos were crucial to help the reader really understand, to see so many places and hear so many different perspectives. An interactive map helped readers see how impacts would be different based on different water levels. And the editor moderated a public forum. The state later began to hold public hearings. It was well packaged in print and online, easy to read and navigate. Very smart, important work.”

Finalists

The Courier-Journal at Louisville
Laura Ungar, reporter

For Laura Ungar’s report about the growing number of babies born addicted to prescription pain killers their mothers took while pregnant.

Judges said: “More than half the babies in a hospital’s NICU unit on one day were addicted newborns. Laura told the stories of these babies, their mothers, their counselors and their caregivers. Videos were a crucial component, necessary to help the reader meet and understand the mothers and to see how addicted babies behave. The coverage was helpful, including ways a parent can soothe an agitated baby, how to tell if you have a prescription drug problem, and how to volunteer. The package explored treatment options and funding solutions. It was packaged in an inviting way; it was easy to navigate and not overwhelming. The story stirred community conversation. Laura appeared on CNN, was asked to present at a legislative oversight committee, to speak at a conference of educators and counselors. The state attorney’s office, an anti-drug organization and the Kentucky Hospital Association circulated the stories to their stakeholders.”

Detroit Free Press
Lori Brasier and Gina Damron, staff writers; Amalie Nash, deputy metro editor; and staff

For a Detroit Free Press series, ‘Free to Kill,’ about slipshod supervision of violent parolees and others on probation who went on to commit more violent crimes. By writers Lori Brasier and Gina Damron, and deputy metro editor Amalie Nash.

Judges said: “Based on a tip after an 80-year-old woman was killed, Brasier and Damron broke the story that two parolees who killed her had not been taken into custody despite being suspects in three police investigations. They then expanded their reporting over seven months and found that was not unusual. They fought for public records. They relied equally on documents and tragic personal stories. They added content best suited to digital — complete documents, videos and resource materials. The package was well organized online, very easy to follow. Detroit followed with a strong editorial and told readers how to submit an effective FOIA request. As a result, the state Department of Corrections began to make immediate changes — reopening a prison to house parole violators and auditing caseloads. A state lawmaker introduced legislation.”

The Tennessean at Nashville
Brian Haas and Tony Gonzalez, reporters

For a report by Brian Haas and Tony Gonzalez that revealed gang violence was growing at double the rate in rural areas as in urban areas.

Judges said: “The Tennessean smartly followed up on an issue it had been following for several years. They maintained an attention span on the issue, but broke new ground. They documented a crime trend that leaders in the small communities had not recognized or acknowledged. They made smart use of documents and data. . They used video. to take readers right to a troubled park to talk to people affected and to an accused gang member. For the first time, a mayor acknowledged the problem, on video. The community has since held graffiti cleanup events, added gang police training and started to rally neighborhoods.”

The Cincinnati Enquirer
Barry Horstman, investigative reporter

For Barry Horstman’s examination of problems in Ohio’s election system that could affect the November elections.

Judges said: “In a project called Protect Your Vote, Barry alerted Ohioans and the nation that Ohio fails to count thousands of provisional ballots each year, threatening individuals’ right to have their vote counted and threatening a timely and accurate count for the national election. He examined documents, scrutinized poll worker training and examined problems found in past elections. He also broke the news that the Ohio Secretary of State was making potential partisan decisions and creating uneven voting rules around the state. And he did a video report to summarize the complicated issue, as another way to tell the story. The Enquirer provided information to help readers ensure their vote counts. It showed readers online how to properly submit a provisional ballot. Barry’s work was picked up nationally; he appeared twice on MSNBC and his work was cited in a New York Times editorial. Requests for absentee ballots are three times higher than in 2008, and election officials credited Enquirer coverage. “

Division II

First Place

The Burlington Free Press
Mike Donoghue, reporter

For a revealing investigative series that took a close look at corruption and a lack of oversight within the Vermont State Police Department. The series focused on a trooper who abused the system, which was scrutinized by the paper and later the state itself.

Judges said: “Reporter Mike Donoghue uncovered a great story by filing a simple Freedom of Information request for employee salary information, which led to a blockbuster series on corruption, fraud and the non-existent oversight in the Vermont State Police. Donoghue did a fantastic job informing readers at every step in the series, and he provided all the details that forced the state police to look at their internal failings and led to the indictment of former sergeant Jim Deeghan. Donoghue did an excellent job turning routine records requests into a series that shined the light on a powerful institution. The reporting was fair, well-sourced and riveting. The presentation, especially the Aug. 10 cover, was excellent. This series served the public on many levels, and Donoghue’s dogged approach to the topic forced officials to take action against one of their own.”

Finalists

Statesman Journal at Salem
Staff

For a five-part series on the housing crisis and its lasting effects on the Salem market and the taxpayers who call western Oregon home.

Judges said: “This ambitious series tackled the elephant in the room for local economies and homeowners across the country: the housing meltdown. Instead of offering readers dry, boring stories filled with numbers, the staff of the Statesman Journal wrote informative, easy-to-read pieces, put together interesting info boxes and sidebars in print, and hit an absolute home run with a great digital package on the website. Though the presentation, writing and photography in print were strong, what set this entry apart was the superb, interactive digital tool.”

Argus Leader at Sioux Falls
Jonathan Ellis, reporter

For a hard-hitting series of stories on a county detox center that came under scrutiny following a string of allegations about unsafe practices and improper procedures made by former and current staff members.

Judges said: “Reporter Jonathan Ellis did a great job pulling together sourcing to give life to a story about unsafe conditions at the local center. If it were not for Ellis and his commitment to bring the ongoing issues to the attention of the community, it is possible the violations and the problems that existed at the Minnehaha Detox Center would still be an issue today. Ellis and the Argus Leader put the issue on the front page, local leaders were forced to react, and the state eventually showed up to confirm what Ellis began uncovering with his first story. Ellis also worked to include named sources rather than to simply use anonymous sources to protect former and current employees.

Division III

First Place

The News-Star at Monroe
Tabby Soignier, reporter; and staff

For reporter Tabby Soignier and other staff members clear and personal reporting of the stories of cancer in their community.

Judges said: “Reporter Tabby Soignier bravely fought a rare form of ovarian cancer — a battle that she later turned into a personal tale of survival. In the newspaper’s coverage of cancer awareness, Soignier, a sports reporter, shared her story of battling cancer while other staffers chronicled the stories of those in their community who lived to tell their tales. The coverage vividly put a face on the disease, allowing readers to understand the disease’s impacts on their neighbors’ lives. The newspaper also supported the Komen Foundation’s Race for the Cure, allowing residents to act on the emotions the stories evoked. A newspaper editorial clearly outlined a call to action: Participate to help people fight cancer and raise awareness. The newspaper then went on to cover the race, celebrating their participation with coverage in print and online.”

Finalists

The Daily News Journal at Murfreesboro
Mark Bell and Scott Broden, staff writers

For reporting by Mark Bell and Scott Broden that puts a face on the homeless in the city, taking the lead in the community conversation when city officials seemed reluctant to do so.

Judges said: “Reporter Mark Bell and Scott Broden started with this story: A city fireman had posted a photo of a homeless woman on Facebook and then proceeded to berate her in a personal post. Almost no one “official” wanted to comment. So the reporters went out and led the community conversation on the topic. Was there a homeless problem? How could people help? The reporters documented the problem and its nuances in ensuing coverage (including a three-part series) that allowed readers to understand what the problem is, meet those who were homeless and find ways to help through local charities that provide services to the homeless in the region. This project showed leadership on a topic where no one else seemed to want to take the podium to discuss.”

Iowa City Press-Citizen
Lee Hermiston, reporter

For reporter Lee Hermiston’s detailed and solution-oriented coverage of efforts to pass a ballot measure to build a new county justice center and jail.

Judges said: “Reporter Lee Hermiston went beyond the rhetoric in this entry to really tell taxpayers whether they should consider paying more for a new justice center and jail. The coverage clearly details problems with the system as is: It’s not ADA-compliant, attorneys and clients have no privacy, the front entry can’t be secured, only one elevator exists in the building and it’s used by everyone. But it also details how taxpayers continue to pay for these poor conditions because they house their inmates in surrounding counties. That means the taxpayers are paying for all the surrounding counties’ jail improvements and facilities. Coverage of the ballot initiative included a video detailing the issues with the jail and a photo gallery – giving readers a first-row seat. It also engaged readers by inviting them to participate in the online debate, voicing their opinions before the issue went to voters on Nov. 6.”

In-Depth Journalism
Division I

First Place

The Journal News at Westchester
Gary Stern and Mareesa Nicosia, reporters; Peter Carr, photographer

For a comprehensive examination of the Rockland East Ramapo school district and the deep divide that exists in the community over how to fund the public schools. The debate has been fueled by religious, cultural and ethnic differences, which has left the fate of the local schools in question.

Judges said: “This is a remarkable piece of journalism. Reporters Gary Stern and Mareesa Nicosia provided readers with all the details about the ugly debate that has erupted over the public schools in the East Ramapo district, and they did so with style, grace and great sensitivity. The Journal News put this important story in proper context for readers, and the interactive digital component was simply outstanding. The packaging, in print and online, was thoughtful, and the readers in Westchester are fortunate to have the Journal News to deliver the details on such an important topic.”

Finalists

The Clarion-Ledger at Jackson, Miss.
Jerry Mitchell, reporter; Debbie Skipper, assistant managing editor

For a detailed exposé on the abuse of prescription drugs in Mississippi. The Clarion-Ledger detailed how “doctor shopping” has become commonplace in the state because the majority of doctors do not utilize a prescription drug monitoring program.

Judges said: “Reporter Jerry Mitchell did a wonderful job of digging up details and painting a picture of poor oversight by doctors, the state and the players in the pharmaceutical industry. Mitchell brought this layered package together with versatile reporting, and the result is what in-depth journalism is all about. Readers thanked The Clarion-Ledger for this series, and for good reason.”

The Indianapolis Star
Michael Boren, reporter

For a moving piece on the devastating impact heroin has had on families and small towns in Indiana.

Judges said: “Reporter Michael Boren did a masterful job of weaving together details about the tragic death of 18-year-old Cierra Adams, and how heroin has changed life for many in small towns across the Hoosier state. The video accompanying the story was dramatic and well done.”

FLORIDA TODAY at Brevard
Todd Halvorson, NASA and space launch reporter; Tim Walters, visuals editor

For comprehensive coverage of NASA’s ‘Curiosity’ rover project, which broke new ground in the space industry and thrilled engineers, scientists, school teachers and lovers of space.

Judges said: “Todd Halvorson and Tim Walters gave readers a front-row seat for this exciting venture, and the depth and breadth of the coverage on multiple platforms was impressive. The video work was strong, especially the raw video of reaction to the successful landing of Curiosity.”

Division II

First Place

St. Cloud Times
Kevin Allenspach, reporter; Kimm Anderson, photojournalist

For reporter Kevin Allenspach and photojournalist Kimm Anderson’s work documenting the economic impact of North Dakota oil fields in central Minnesota. The comprehensive five-part series looked at how the Williston, N.D., region has helped businesses and individuals weather the recession — and get paid well, in an area that sees an unemployment rate of just 1 percent.

Judges said: “Kevin Allenspach and Kimm Anderson spent a year researching, interviewing and being out in the fields — literally — to bring to readers a very rich, informative and exceptionally well-written series about how the Bakken oil fields have helped Minnesotans. The end product clearly shows that this was time well-spent. Allenspach does a terrific job of storytelling and intimately bringing the readers into the worlds of the many people involved in the success of the Bakken oil fields, while also craftily weaving in the economic and business elements of the story. Anderson’s photos are also outstanding, showing the everyday lives of those who have been impacted and the world they work in.”

Finalists

Courier-Post at Cherry Hill
Lucas K. Murray, reporter

For Lucas K. Murray’s riveting story about prostitutes’ lives on the dangerous streets of Camden.

Judges said: “In order to tell the tales of prostitutes in Camden, Lucas K. Murray goes right into their world and spends time bearing witness to the daily struggle of drugs and addiction that is their lives. The time Murray spent with them is invaluable, as he is able to connect and engage with them as they reflect on their emotional stories and give readers a glimpse of the vicious cycle of drugs, addiction and desperation.”

Asheville Citizen-Times
John Boyle, reporter

For a story that pieces together details — revealed for the first time — leading up to a gruesome fatal knife fight.

Judges said: “With little help from authorities, John Boyle set out to answer the many questions still remaining after a knife fight at a local bar left three men dead — including the perpetrator — and one man critically injured. Boyle conducted extensive interviews with the many witnesses and parties from that night to tell the events leading up to how Steven Wike, a man friends have described as having turned his life around and often helping the homeless, could have committed a crime so gruesome. Through details Boyle was able to uncover and the insights from criminology experts, Boyle’s compelling storytelling helped to shed some light on this bizarre and traumatic case.”

Argus Leader at Sioux Falls
John Hult, reporter

For John Hult’s diligent reporting on how the death of a 2-year-old girl went unreported for more than 10 hours. Hult uncovered the deeper issues of the Yankton Sioux tribe that involved meth use and trafficking, the lack of law enforcement and the misuse of federal grants.

Judges said: “Kudos to reporter John Hult for digging hard to uncover the circumstances leading to how a 2-year-old girl died, turning it from a routine but heartbreaking story of kid-dies-under-neglectful-adults’-watch into a much deeper story. Hult examined records and talked to residents, community leaders, law enforcement and experts. His diligent reporting led him to how this poverty-stricken Yankton Sioux community is stricken with meth use and trafficking, exacerbated by conflicting law enforcement jurisdictions, a flawed housing system and misuse of federal grants. One could see the story evolve, from a news story of a child’s death into an enterprise report on the deeper issues affecting the tribe and how it is (as one of the headlines aptly states) “trapped in a meth triangle.”

Division III

First Place

News Journal at Mansfield
Staff

For five days of authoritative solutions-driven coverage from July through August that launched a timely passion topic over jobs — what happened to them and how to get them back.

Judges said: “The staff of the News Journal delivered readers with well-documented series of stories of manageable length that provided the context on jobs before, jobs now and jobs to come. This business package was written clearly and presented in a significant way. Coverage was supplemented by with charts comparing between the prosperity of the past and the developing trends. The voice of everyday people was laced throughout coverage. This package had breadth and provided a realistic perspective on where the jobs market is going.”

Finalists

Battle Creek Enquirer
Justin Hinkley, reporter

For coverage that defined clearly an important social issue — bullying in schools and the reasons we should care about addressing the concern, as told through the potent voices of those who know the pain, children.

Judges said: “Reporter Justin A. Hinkley delivers a sophisticated report on a major social issue of our times in the newspaper’s continuing efforts to improve the lives of children. The clear reporting and writing are supported by trends that should astound any reader of the frequency of bullying and serious consequences. The story gives a strong sense of what constitutes bullying, how it intrudes upon the rights of individuals and delivers resources for help and advice. Accompanying the package was a full page of essays from contributors that defined bullying in an undeniable way. The report was a public service to community.”

The News-Messenger at Fremont
Mark Tower, reporter

For ‘Internet Cafes,’ a three-part head-clearing analysis on “the sweepstakes saga” and the debate over whether the booming business in Ohio is a way for people to mingle socially or merely a booming social disease — gambling with a softer name.

Judges said: “Reporter Mark Tower dives into the controversial debate over the newest business trend in Ohio — sweepstakes cafes with names such as the Lucky Dog, Lot$-A-Fun and Players Club/Internet Cafe. The police and some municipal authorities see this new business purely as a gambling venture but federal law provides cover for sweepstakes and the state has been unable to develop regulatory law, setting off a clash of wills in court. In less than a year, the number of clubs statewide zoomed from 280 to 772. With clear writing and a direct approach, the reporter explains how the new businesses work, provides a good give and take between supporters and opponents and shows what is at stake for all involved in the business — and in the sweepstakes game.”

The Daily Advertiser at Lafayette, La.
Nicholas Persac and Amanda McElfresh, reporters

For a well-written single in-depth story on the environmental challenges of the Atchafalaya Basin, the largest swamp in North America and the showcase of reality TV and gator hunting.

Judges said: “Reporters Nicholas Persac and Amanda McElfresh deliver a descriptive story on the wonders of this animal kingdom with a sense of place that helps you know the swamp, understand needs, and moreover, provide a reason for an insider or outsider to care.”

Breaking News
Division I
First Place

The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Staff

For the Republic’s staff coverage of the last-minute announcement that a four-year FBI criminal investigation into the Maricopa County sheriff and others had been closed.

Judges said: “It’s a challenge to report any story when it happens at 5 pm on a Friday of a three-day weekend. But, in this case, the Republic staff drew on its vast understanding and excellent sourcing to do so with sophistication and analysis in print and online. Staff hit all the hallmarks of good breaking news coverage: instant tweets, documents, blogging and more. But, digitally what stood out about this entry was the depth provided. The web site and its social media outlets provided the instant breaking news, but allowed readers to go deep into the issues and case, giving a narrative context to the breaking news. In print, the staff turned a second-day story that showcased its prowess of the subject matter, providing the behind-the scenes story that gave readers a better understanding. Well done.”

Finalists

Detroit Free Press
Jim Schaefer and Tresa Baldas, staff writers; and staff

For the digital delivery of expert coverage by reporters Jim Schaefer and Tresa Baldas of opening arguments in the federal corruption case against former Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick, his father, a longtime friend and the city’s former water department director. The coverage provided engagement, depth, and library-like context that allowed readers to follow the trial of their mayor with an analytic eye.

Judges said: “A trial opening is one of the few breaking news events for which a newsroom can plan – and the staffers here did, delivering depth digitally. and context in print The staffers found ways to engage readers (a Q&A with court reporter Jim Schaefer). They also timed and prepared their updates for mobile and tablet – having special editions ready to go when the trial started. Live blogging gave readers the blow-by-blow of the trial. The reason this coverage is so effective is because the digital efforts build and highlight the expertise and authority of the reporters. That authoritative tone set this entry apart from others.”

The Courier-Journal at Louisville
Staff

For the Louisville staff coverage of a school bus crash that hurt 51 people and the ensuing chaos as parents desperately tried to get answers about their children.

Judges said: “From the moment the bus crashed, the reporters covering this knew and understood that this was a digital story first. They responded as a Web staff – providing instant information for parents frantic to find their children. The newspaper’s reporting from being at the scene (through video, Twitter, photos and Storify) almost immediately allowed its information to become the authority for parents, who criticized the school district for its slowness in providing answers. In print, the coverage analyzed the chaos of the instead of just rehashing the morning crash. Instead, reporters provided context, data and impact for next-day readers that made the print edition a must-read, too.”

The Clarion-Ledger at Jackson, Miss.
Staff

For the staff coverage of Hurricane Isaac’s touchdown on the Gulf Coast online and in print.

Judges said: “The staff of the Clarion-Ledger is clearly hurricane tested – and they delivered digitally and in print to their readers again this time as another hurricane prepared to hit the Gulf Coast. What impressed about their digital delivery is their understanding of which information belongs online and which belongs in print. They delivered up-to the minute information around the clock. Plus, they quickly gave readers the direction they needed online to find the information. The information was constant and straightforward, complimented by images in video and still photography to show readers what was happening (even if they evacuated the area). In print, they told the stories of precautions, Mother Nature and survival as the storm approached and passed.”

Division II

First Place

St. Cloud Times
Staff

For staff coverage of the announcement to close the 100-year-old Verso Paper Co. and eliminate 259 jobs a few months after an explosion.

Judges said: “The St. Cloud staff used a variety of approaches – video, Cover It Live, Twitter and Facebook – to tell its community that some news was coming, to report the announcement when it happened, to report a variety of reaction, and to engage the community in a conversation about the impact and what’s next. Yet it didn’t sacrifice clarity for volume; it was easy to understand what was going on and what it meant even as the news was happening. The second-day coverage in print was strong. Four pages of coverage included an authoritative, contextual story about the state of the paper industry. And the staff used social media tools to ask readers for ideas for the future of the site.”

Finalists

The Star Press at Muncie
Staff

For The Star Press’ coverage of a four-hour standoff outside a meth house that included robots and armored humvees. The story came days after subscription model launch, and that day’s coverage drove a high volume of activations.

Judges said: “One of the strongest points of the staff’s coverage was the photography. The Star Press used its access to truly tell a visual story throughout the ordeal. Photo coverage online was robust, putting the reader on the scene and close up. The staff maximized that by making smart use of Instagram and posting photos on Facebook. Updates were frequent and the staff showcased them in a strong ‘Breaking News’ red banner. A video play button on the home page showcased storytelling video.”

The Burlington Free Press
John Briggs, reporter; Elliot deBruyn, photographer

For John Briggs’ and Elliot deBruyn’s coverage of a protest that broke out on a Sunday afternoon at a meeting of New England governors and the premier of Quebec.

Judges said: “The story started with smart instincts by photographer Elliot deBruyn, who thought something was up when a group of protesters split off and started their own more raucous demonstration. The video coverage — both the newspaper’s and video it curated — were outstanding. It really put the reader in the middle of the action, close enough to feel the stings, to see first-hand the behaviors of both the protesters and police. They smartly used Twitter and Tumblr to post information and anecdotes as they were happening. But they helped readers see the full picture at the same time by providing a story, even in the middle of the incident, that pulled all the details together.”

Green Bay Press-Gazette
Scott Cooper Williams, reporter

For breaking the news of a gas pipeline leak that sickened one family and threatened to reduce the gas supply across an area of Wisconsin. Scott’s coverage was retweeted by other news outlets.

Judges said: “Some of the best breaking stories are those readers would not know if it weren’t for the newspaper. In this case, Scott used a tip from a gas truck driver to break the news that a gasoline pipeline 100 miles away was leaking, cutting off the flow of 3 million gallons of gas a day to areas all the way north of Milwaukee. He broke the news while the incident was still happening. Scott also found the homeowner on whose property the leak developed, who had to be moved to a hotel because the odor was making his son ill.”

Division III

First Place

Star-Gazette at Elmira
Staff

After a tornado ripped a near 10-mile path through the Elmira metro area on July 26, the staff at the Star-Gazette responded quickly to the unfolding scene even after losing the internet connection in their building. Working with Binghamton, the Elmira staff shared updates on their website and had three full pages inside of storm damage reporting, including lots of photos.

Judges said: “The Star-Gazette staff involved in reporting this storm did a great job of giving a comprehensive report on many platforms. The newspaper’s stories and photos give a good idea of what it was like to be on the ground where the damage was the worst, while still providing public service details on where to go for help.

The online component of the coverage was easy to navigate and full of good content. The content carousel was a nice visual touch. Often with storm coverage there are so many updates that stories end up getting listed on the website but The Star-Gazette’s team created a storm page and organized its content well. The page views report from during the storm showed that thousands of readers were checking the Star-Gazette’s website throughout the night the storm hit. The newspaper and website was the community’s information epicenter.”

Finalists

The News-Star at Monroe
Staff

For The News-Star’s three-day preparation and coverage of Hurricane Isaac in southern Louisiana.

Judges said: “The News-Star staff did an excellent job of providing their audience with tons of information in preparation for Hurricane Isaac. It was apparent the staff was ready and in the field gathering information and bringing it back for their readers. Everything from the front page coverage to the sports pages reflected the focus of this team. There were nice details after the storm passed as well- for instance about the Isaac evacuees finding comfort in a yoga class.”

Outstanding Writing
Division I

First Place

Detroit Free Press
Jo-Ann Barnas, staff writer

For exceptional narrative storytelling that the reader can see, hear and feel on two great athletes from Michigan who excelled at the summer Olympics in boxing and gymnastics.

Judges said: “Reporter Jo-Ann Barnas lifts the reader into the seats with words with her story on boxing. You see the fight. You can feel the tension. You can hear the crowd. “”Ole! Ole! Ole! Ole!”” fill the arena in the story on boxing phenom Claressa Shields.

The second entry is a social media narrative on the U.S. gymnastics team with 29 Twitter posts. This was concise storytelling executed in a compelling way.

Coverage concludes with a third narrative, a memorable story on the winning women’s gymnastic team and the “golden redemption” of Michigan’s Jordyn Wieber.

The stories are of manageable length for reader. The stories are full of emotion. The stories are conversational. The stories show rather than tell. This is what emphatic narrative writing is all about.”

Finalists

Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
David Andreatta, reporter

For a two-part package with clear, crisp and compelling storytelling on the difficult subject of infant death in Rochester. The stories had impact.

Judges said: “David Andreatta has a smooth voice that carries through from the start of every story to the end. Included in the entry are videos. The writer narrated the first video. His voice on video is every bit as strong as his writing voice. His stories are tightly written. Length is manageable for the reader. He has a way of opening up everyday sources who have endured the death of an infant. Importantly, he carries a crusading touch to his delivery that does not get in the way of the story. His approach tells the reader that he knows this topic is important, and that he is an empathetic listener.”

The Cincinnati Enquirer
John Erardi, sports storyteller; Jeff Swinger, photojournalist

For a tightly written feature story that was a delight to read — the best night Teddy Kremer ever experienced when he was chosen batboy for the Reds.

Judges said: “Reporter John Erardi and photographer Jeff Swinger produced a charming feature story, starting with the conversational lead and ending with a memorable ending. This feature held together nicely. It’s the story of a young man with Down syndrome. He is 29. He loves his team. He is chosen to do the job at one special game. What proceeds is a magical night for Teddy, his family, the team and the reader.”

The Clarion-Ledger at Jackson, Miss.
Alex McDaniel, social media editor

For a heartfelt narrative about death and how a community comes together to care for itself on a high school football field in New Albany, Mississippi.

Judges said: “Reporter Alex McDaniel writes a story with strong sense of place about a football game dedicated to “AP” — Amanda Price. The coach in New Albany is Ron Price. This is his first night on the field since his wife was murdered as he tried valiantly to shield her from an assailant. Ron and Amanda were high school sweethearts. She died in her own house. She left behind a daughter, 4-year-old, Molly. On the surface, this is such a sad story, but the reporter helps the reader finds strength in the comforting embrace of community.”

The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Karina Bland, reporter

For a story that captures the fascinating engagement between tough-looking bikers with a soft spot for protecting children who have been abused and remain frightened because of the terrifying circumstances involving adults in their lives.

Judges said: “Detail is the calling card for reporter Karina Bland. The writer paints a descriptive image of these bikers, “Fierce protectors,” who carry colorful street monikers and provide calm for children. Great description and great ending.”

Division II

First Place

Statesman Journal at Salem
Cara Pallone, reporter

For a collection of Cara Pallone columns about people who came together to bring closure for the loved ones of a WWII soldier, an unusual pair who dress as superheroes to help the homeless, and community rallying around a 70-year-old man hit by a car.

Judges said: “Cara’s pieces are smart, mid-length narratives, putting the reader right in the middle of relationships and conversations. She uses chronology well. Sentence structure is simple and active with smart turns of phrase. Her endings are inspiring or surprising. Cara leaves you wanting to meet every one of her subjects.”

Finalists

The Burlington Free Press
Candace Page, reporter

For a collection of Candace Page stories about the aftermath of Tropical Storm Irene, an impassioned community fight against wind turbines, and the universal truths of an annual meat fest.

Judges said: “Candace chooses outstanding subject matter, situations that truly advance understanding of the community’s personality. She doesn’t preach. She describes relationships, through dialogue and anecdotes. The tops of her stories are intriguing and the endings are intentional. She uses strong words – shoving, sodden, tilted, leaned, clustered, tapping… She uses direct quotes not just to communicate what someone said but to paint a picture of who they are. She is a classic storyteller.”

The Times at Shreveport
Roy Lang III, editor

For Roy Lang’s unusual approach to a universal situation — the death of his long-time dog.

Judges said: “Probably thousands of columnists have written about the death of a pet and tugged heartstrings. But Roy’s approach to her death and his approach to the writing of it was unconventional. He planned a touching farewell week for his 15-year-old cocker spaniel, created a community in the process and took readers through the week with him. It was not overwrought, just honest, sometimes funny and every line sweet.

Division III

First Place

Times Recorder at Zanesville
Kathy Thompson, staff writer

For three stories reporter Kathy Thompson wrote about the shocking murder of a Canton woman.

Judges said: “The three stories reporter Kathy Thompson crafted about the horrific murder of Celeste Fronsman are absolutely riveting, and an example for all writers to turn to when looking for great work. The flow of the writing is wonderful, and though the details are gut-wrenching in many instances, Thompson helps the reader care about people many in society have decided to forget. Thompson introduces the reader to the victim, who was caught in a ring of friends who were more interested in getting high than anything else. Yet, Thompson’s story about Fronsman’s friends charged with the unspeakable crime, forces the reader to look at this tragic tale from a different perspective. This is aggressive reporting, wonderful writing and outstanding journalism, all rolled into one. Head and shoulders above the other strong entries in the category.”

Finalists

Coshocton Tribune
Valerie Boateng, staff writer

For reporter Valerie Boateng’s story of one woman’s struggle to overcome a variety of challenges tied to homelessness.

Judges said: “Reporter Valerie Boateng handled a sensitive topic, a homeless woman’s struggle to survive, and gave readers great detail through strong storytelling. The story was so well written it was hard to read; the harsh reality of being homeless is brought home time and time again in the piece. Boateng wrote the piece to mark the one-year anniversary of a homeless shelter, and it was an excellent example of how good writing can make a routine story something special.”

The Spectrum at St. George
Lisa Larson, reporter

For reporter Lisa Larson’s profile of a 4-year-old autistic boy and his mother’s struggle to cope with his unique needs in a family with seven children.

Judges said: “This story is wonderful on many levels, and reporter Lisa Larson did an excellent job giving readers everything they need to know about 4-year-old Logan Nagy. And she did so without writing a hundred inches on the topic. Too many entries in this category were overwritten and much longer than they needed to be, but Larson’s piece was perhaps the shortest and one of the best written of the bunch. This was an inviting story, informative and not overwhelming.”

The News Leader at Staunton
Maria Longley, staff writer

For reporter Maria Longley’s collection of three unrelated stories that were featured on Sunday front pages.

Judges said: “Maria Longley showed great versatility and strong writing skills throughout the three stories submitted with this entry. She did a nice job of leading the readers through the story, with the proper pace and delivery, and it’s clear Longley spent some quality time with her subjects. The storytelling is strong, and the piece about the DeJarnette complex is filled with excellent detail. Each piece was easy to read, tightly written and informative.”

Multimedia Storytelling
Division I

First Place

The Journal News at Westchester
Chris Brown, visual journalist; Carucha Meuse and Ricky Flores, photographers; Gary Stern and Mareesa Nicosia, reporters; Peter Carr, photographer

For LoHud.com’s investigation of Rockland’s dysfunctional East Ramapo school district. It’s a taxpayer-funded system, but is run by an ultra-Orthodox board majority. Those board members won’t send their own kids to the public schools, yet are making lasting and controversial decisions that have sparked bitter protests along racial and religious lines.

Judges said: “LoHud.com’s multimedia presentation of Rockland’s East Ramapo school district was rich with content that gave context to a complicated community issue. The video intro holds your interest and provides a good overview for the subject matter while the interactive maps give the viewer the power to navigate through ample information. The ‘Who’s on the school board’ interactive photo was clever. This project should serve as an example of ways we can be dynamic and interactive with our storytelling.”

Finalists

Detroit Free Press
Staff

The staff at the Free Press produced playful multimedia content for the Woodward Dream Cruise, an annual event that draws in car lovers.

Judges said: “The Detroit Free Press’ coverage of the Woodward Dream Cruise is interactive, entertaining and playful. The video ‘50 Shades of Dream Cruise‘ with Zlati Meyer was quick and funny with sharp editing. The staff produced an engine sound quiz which this judge completely failed to pass but that I’m sure car lovers enjoyed. It was apparent the staff involved with this project planned well and had some fun along the way.”

The News Journal at Wilmington
Staff

For multimedia coverage of the Firefly Music Festival by the staff of The News Journal and delawareonline.

Judges said: “The blog-like design of the website created by The News Journal for the Firefly Music festival has a clean feeling that serves the videos and content well on the website. Interactive social media elements let the readers dig in and engage. Along with basic information about the festival (maps, band bios) there are festival vignettes featuring the performers, the scene and the festival attendees which surely helped draw in young readers.”

Division II

First Place

Statesman Journal at Salem
Staff

For the Statesman Journal’s examination into why the foreclosure and housing crisis of 2008 will have a lasting impact in Salem. The well focused stories were personalized and allowed readers to examine the impact with depth.

Judges said: “The Salem staff examined the housing crisis with depth and personality, giving readers online a multi-layered understanding of the story. What set this entry apart from the others was the online storytelling that allowed the reader a narrative constructed through data, videos, social media and timelines. The framework built to tell the story made this a meaningful and easy to follow multimedia story. The data interactives were compelling in this piece – allowing the reader to visualize the foreclosure growth, explain their own housing situation and see the pattern of the housing crisis in their own neighborhoods. Well done.”

Finalists

Lansing State Journal
Staff

For the staff’s examination of those who are unemployed in Lansing, providing personal stories as well as data that made the explosion of the problem easy to visualize and understand.

Judges said: “The Lansing staff examined getting a job in the new, leaner aftermath of an economy. To do that, they personally connected readers to the issue – allowing readers to meet those going through such hiring in videos and slideshows. The staff also put together compelling interactives allowing readers to play with the data, providing the context needed to explain the employers’ selective position on hiring. That data visualization allowed those without significant statistical experience to easily understand the issue at hand.”

Poughkeepsie Journal
Chrissie Williams and Darryl Bautista, videographers; Mary Beth Pfeiffer, reporter; Irwin Goldberg, digital editor

For the pieces by reporter Mary Beth Pfeiffer, videographers Chrissie Williams and Darryl Bautista and Digital Editor Irwin Goldberg connecting readers with their experiences with Lyme disease.

Judges said: “Reporter Mary Beth Pfeiffer’s investigation into Lyme disease detailed that Dutchess County was the top county for Lyme disease in America. And she told that story digitally as well as in print. An interactive map allows readers to find their counties’ own infection rates – setting the base of the story and providing the data to give context. Videographers captured the stories of those who had the disease or spent chunks of their lives trying to find answers. But the staff didn’t just rely on video. They used Storify to aggregate the massive reaction they received from readers, allowing one another to share resources and stories. Live chats allowed the audience to discuss the disease. The microsite created by the staffers allows the aggregation of all things Lyme disease in one spot, allowing readers unparalleled depth on the topic.”

Press & Sun-Bulletin at Binghamton
Jeff Platsky, digital editor; David Robinson, staff reporter

For Digital Editor Jeff Platsky and staff reporter David Robinson’s online storytelling of Binghamton’s Restaurant Week.

Judges said: “Reporter Jeff Platsky and David Robinson worked to tell the story of Binghamton’s Restaurant Week in advance by engaging reader participation, real-time through Twitter, Storify and Instagram and then curating that participation into an all encompassing site that told the story through aggregated tweets, photos and mapping. The participation of readers made this coverage work. The devised their coverage for each platform: In print they wrote advances to encourage participation and online they covered the actual event by asking all those folks who went out to eat to pick up their smartphones and tweet or take a photo of their food (yep, there was even a half-eaten hamburger in the bunch). This coverage engaged readers in a fun, storytelling way that ended with an online recap of the week (if you didn’t make it to each restaurant). The fact that they compiled their social engagement at the finale to capture the story is what set this entry apart from others.”

Division III

First Place

The News Leader at Staunton
Mike Tripp, chief photojournalist

For Mike Tripp’s multimedia package that was a result of his curiosity when he saw a donut shop pop up alongside a popular road.

Judges said: “Mike Tripp gives a good example of how effective multimedia storytelling doesn’t always have to be hard and serious news. His interest was piqued when he saw a donut stop, so naturally he investigated and produced a nice package. The video was well done with good audio — both the subject’s voiceover and the nat sound of donuts frying — and great visuals. I could smell the donuts as I was watching the video! The photo gallery also gave readers a nice glimpse into how a mobile donut truck operates.”

Visual Journalism: Design
Division I
First Place

Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Leah Balconi, custom content editor

For an iPad Fall Cultural Arts Preview bonus content through the Rochester Magazine app.

Judges said: “The presentation, layout and navigation of the Fall Cultural Arts Preview app content is impressive from the get-go. Art is effectively used as a traditional dominant “centerpiece” with each category, yet the layout and function is anything but traditional. Multiple photos and videos are smartly incorporated without cluttering the page. Reading and jumping to different sections is intuitive. All the features enhance the user experience. And the content shows the ease and familiarity the writers have with the arts and entertainment scene. This is not just great visual design, it’s also functional design that is a practical, great resource for readers to have.”

Finalists

The Courier-Journal at Louisville
Brian Gray, designer

For the bold and creative entertainment pages that shout to readers.

Judges said: “All entertainment pages require creativity, but Brian Gray’s work screams out to readers that this is no ordinary entertainment section. His ability to take routine publicity stills and turn them into original and enticing illustrations is exceptional. Gray does this through original ideas that expand the theme of the subject matter, smart use of subtle details that enhance the design and great use of fonts that help give readers a feel for the story.”

The Cincinnati Enquirer
Carl Weiser, political editor; Mike Nyerges, graphic journalist; Mark Wert, investigations and data editor

For the effective and informative graphical presentation detailing how Ohio is THE battleground state.

Judges said: “To effectively explain in words and numbers the details of Ohio’s crucial role in the election is already hard enough. To be able to pull it off graphically … is wholly impressive. The Enquirer did just that with a two-page presentation that took loads of historical and current information, data and endless analyses and condensed it all into a handsome, reader-friendly package. Through smart, simple use of color — a neutral backdrop, major graphic elements in hues of blue and red — and the right combination of art and words, readers get the “”nut grafs”” quickly and concisely.

The two graphical pages also translated well to the web through the use of Prezi, which continued the theme of chunking — giving readers a piece of rich information at one time so as to not overwhelm with so much data.”

The Arizona Republic at Phoenix
Republic Media and Design Studio staff

For the new and bolder integrated azcentralsports multi-platform section.

Judges said: “AZCentralSports wanted to be bolder after integrating the sports brand with 12 News. It’s no question that bold is definitely the word to describe the endeavor. With outstanding art played dominantly accompanied by great use of text and original illustrations, the Wow factor is there to grab readers right away — and the content keeps them. The little touches of column sigs and refers also make the overall page design stand out.”

Division II

First Place

Great Falls Tribune
Staff

For the newspaper’s redesigned “My Montana” section, which is a passion-topic section that celebrates all things about Big Sky Country.

Judges said: “Big, bold photos with lots of airy space is the hallmark description of the newly revamped section My Montana at the Great Falls Tribune. It’s also an apt description for the state. The section reflects the celebration of the Big Sky Country’s way of life through stories, images and standing feature. Design is intuitive, clear and sophisticated. The vertical guide on the cover leads readers to what’s inside. The section proves to have high utility, with tidbits of information tucked into the design (example, “You might be a Montanan if …”) . Well crafted section.”

Finalist

Statesman Journal at Salem
K. Williams Brown, columnist; Claudia Saavedra, designer at the Phoenix Design Studio

For columnist K. Williams Brown’s adieu on a Statesman Journal microsite that gives readers 10 entry points to her goodbye.

Judges said: “When Salem columnist K. Williams Brown signed a book deal, she gave up her column in the Statesman Journal. And to say goodbye to her readers, she decided to take to the Internet. What came from that is a lively goodbye that seems to reflect her columns. It has a crisp, clear design that tells the story of the countdown to her absence from the paper, giving readers ways to remember and relive her columns.”

The Burlington Free Press
Danielle Morris, designer, Asbury Park Design Studio; Nicole Haley, ARTSbtv editor, Burlington Free Press

For designer Danielle Morris and ARTSbtv Editor Nicole Haley’s design of the ARTSbtv section in the Burlington Free Press.

Judges said: “Style is what sets this design entry apart from the others. Arts editor Nicole Haley and designer Danielle Morris designed a section that is user-friendly, focusing on crisp entry points, simplicity and big, bold art. The section’s design captures and reflects the quirkiness of the stories and really proves to be an intricate part of the section’s mission. The design and content run seamlessly, making separating the two nearly impossible. Well done.”

St. Cloud Times
Lisa Mueller and the Heartland Team at the Des Moines Design Studio

For a collection of intricate graphics by Lisa Mueller and the Heartland Team that brought clarity to complex stories in a range of ways.

Judges said: “The graphics were stories unto themselves. One example broke down complex local financial figures, a second helped introduce administrators and key data on area school districts and a third brought readers on a journey local history from 150 years ago. The graphics conveyed lots of information in a simple, crisp and easy-to-use formats. In addition to being highly informative and organized, each graphic had a distinct style that made readers feel like they were getting something truly special. Key to the success in each of these is how both Mueller and the Heartland Team get organized early in the reporting process to help deliver such complete packages.”

Division III

First Place

The News Leader at Staunton
News Leader and Nashville Design Studio staff

For the News Leader’s redesign of their Sunday newspaper from four sections to five sections which features a more magazine style A-section.

Judges said: “The News Leader’s new sections are simple, direct and compelling. The magazine style A-sections and inside sections use photographs effectively, highlighting strong work and strengthening the draw to stories. They also give the sky boxes room to breathe which is refreshing. Good to see a newspaper making calculated design changes to produce a fresher product.”

Finalists

Oshkosh Northwestern
Oshkosh Northwestern; Wisconsin Team, Des Moines Design Studio staffs

For the Oshkosh Northwestern’s design treatment of the annual EAA AirVenture.

Judges said: “The oversized skyboxes featuring planes in the EAA AirVenture are fun and an effective way of keeping the community’s big story on the front page over a prolonged coverage period. The ‘Love in flight’ page is especially graphic and captivating. It would be easy to imagine readers in this community excited to see the paper each day.”

Star-Gazette at Elmira
Asbury Park Design Studio staff

For the Elmira Star-Gazette’s 12-page special section called “Weathering the storm” about the tornado devastation that cut a nearly 10-mile path into the city.

Judges said: “The power of this special section comes from its size and the strong use of photographs and white space to create balanced pages that capture a reader’s attention. This was a huge story for the Elmira community and the newspaper responded with a section that was well designed and thoughtful. One can imagine that this would be a section readers would save to remember the big tornado.”

Visual Storytelling: Photo/Video
Division I

First Place

The Courier-Journal at Louisville
Matt Stone, staff photographer

For the amazing video work produced by Matt Stone that spans all subject matters and showcases his versatility in visual storytelling.

Judges said: “It takes a special talent to be able to make viewers laugh out loud from one video and then wipe away sorrowful tears because of another. But that’s exactly what photographer Matt Stone can do with his exceptionally well-produced and powerful videos. The wide variety of videos Stone produces showcases his visual storytelling ability, from a fun video about a woman who predicts the weather using persimmon seeds to the heartbreaking story of the southeastern Indiana family that died in a tornado — and their toddler who somehow initially survived and was found in a field but died days later. Stone lets the subjects talk in their own words, and moves the video along with cuts, outstanding shots from unique angles and appropriate music; nothing over the top or too corny. Stone’s work leaves you nearly speechless, being only able to say, ‘Wow.’

Finalists

Detroit Free Press
Patricia Beck, staff photographer

For a long-form video and photo essay from Patricia Beck that examines and chronicles the first year of NBA star Jalen Rose’s Leadership Academy charter school and its impact on struggling students.

Judges said: “Staff photographer Patricia Beck spent a year inside the new Jalen Rose Leadership Academy, working with students and staff in order to earn their trust and give a voice and face to struggling students. Beck’s long-form video is nicely done, with great storytelling and visuals. She deftly combines a variety of b-roll and stills to accompany the voiceover, interviews and subtle use of music to move the video along. Her focus on one particular troubled student does what the finest journalists have done so well: make the viewer FEEL something. And in this case, it’s to sympathize and care.

Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Marie De Jesus, photographer

For a video series produced by Marie De Jesus for the Rochester Democrat and Chronicle called “Gone too soon,” about the high rate of infant mortality deaths in Monroe County.

Judges said: “This four part video series produced by Rochester photographer Marie De Jesus and reporter David Andreatta displays a level of intimacy and sensitivity toward a difficult subject matter. The work is informative and emotional, and is effective in putting a face to the statistics. Destiny’s Story captures sweet, intimate moments along with the total heartbreak the parent’s feel for the loss of their child. Although many of the entries in this category used a variety of multimedia platforms and social media strategies to tell their stories, the simplicity and strength of the storytelling earned this entry a finalist award.”

The Indianapolis Star
Staff

For the Indianapolis Star’s Labor Day video profiles on those who work the shift when most of us sleep: the Invisible Shift.

Judges said: “To commemorate Labor Day, The Indianapolis Star did a nice job spotlighting the laborers who work third shift, or what the Indy Star calls ‘The Invisible Shift.’ The multimedia component of the project does a great job of giving readers a first-hand look at what goes on during the wee hours of the night/morning. There’s a nice mix of b-roll and stills to tell the stories of these workers — all in their own words. The b-rolls are excellent and show the skill and dedication of the videographers. This is especially evident when watching the shots from inside a fire truck that is responding, and when watching newborn puppies emerge from a 24-hour emergency veterinary clinic.”

The News Journal at Wilmington
Andre Smith, lead videographer/web developer

For a series of high school football videos produced by Andre Smith, showcasing his technical expertise as well as his immense knowledge of prep football.

Judges said: “After watching the News Journal’s prep football videos, it’s fair to say every town and city in the U.S. crazy about high school football probably wishes it had Andre Smith in their community. Smith does it all: shoots, edits, writes and narrates the 60 to 90 second snapshot videos of the night’s big high school games. Shooting — and capturing key moments — of a football game is no easy feat. But somehow Smith always seems to be in the right spot at the right time to get crisp, tight shots of touchdowns and big plays reminiscent of what you’d see on ESPN. Making the endeavor even more impressive is that he then entirely produces the video from start to finish. The editing and cuts are fast to match the tone of the video. His recaps show his immense knowledge of not just the sport, but each team. The writing is quick but fun. And it certainly helps to have great audio cues so that when he’s talking about a 40-yard run, the viewer does indeed see that exact play. Smith is the total video package.”

Division II

First Place

Poughkeepsie Journal
Christina Williams, Darryl Bautista, multimedia producers; Nina Schutzman, reporter

For an emotional story of a dad coming home from war and surprising his two boys at school. If this video story doesn’t make you tear up, nothing will.

Judges said: “This is teamwork in a hurry. Christina Williams, Darryl Bautista and Nina Schutzman worked well with IPhone and video camera to first move video fast and raw to online and then into a polished form. The short video held together as a complete story.”

Finalists

The Burlington Free Press
Elliot deBruyn, photographer/videographer

For a video with a story line that showcased Burlington at a carefree moment. Behold, the midsummer Festival of Fools. Let the wacky fun begin.

Judges said: “Photographer Elliot deBruyn captures sense of place with a grin in this video story. He relies on the antics of street performers and the thread of charming carnvial music to entrance. The story was artfully woven together in a cohesive way.”

Courier-Post at Cherry Hill
Chris LaChall, photographer

For a single powerful picture of prostitution on the streets of Cherry Hill, the lead photo in an in-depth story, “This is no way to live.”

Judges said: “Chris LaChall captures the raw grit of life, a facet of the community that ought to appear more in our products.”

Great Falls Tribune
Larry Beckner, photo editor

For four sports photos with brilliant clarity.

Judges said: “Larry Beckner finds a unique moment of action in each of these pictures. He also demonstrates range, covering minor-league baseball, prep football and professional rodeo. In each case, Beckner got to the heart of each athlete’s physical exertion, competitiveness and focus. The emotions Beckner captured, whether from a running back staving off a tackle, a runner spraying dirt diving into a base or a bulldogger wrestling a steer, painted intimate portraits one could never see from the stands or even the sidelines.”

Division III

First Place

Herald Times Reporter at Manitowoc
Matthew Apgar, photographer

For Matthew Apgar’s photography and video footage of commercial fishing in Two Rivers for the Herald Times Reporter.

Judges said: “Good community photojournalism shows readers aspects of people’s lives that go beneath the surface. Obviously, this requires a level of commitment and no small amount of time to tell a story with depth and personality and both aspects were evident in The Herald Times Reporter’s Matthew Apgar photo story about the fisherman with the Susie Q Fish Market in Two Rivers. Apgar’s images are well composed, using layering to give his images depth and complexity (see image of Jeremy Kulpa tossing a fish back into Lake Michigan). In addition to the standard action shots that show the process of fishing in Lake Michigan, Apgar caught some of the quieter moments of this sort of life (see Jon Kulpa slipping on his rubber boots). This judge finds these sorts of images most compelling because anyone can capture decent images of fisherman hauling fish into a boat, but it takes patience, an eye, and a level of comfort with your subjects to capture these quiet, more unexpected moments. This judge encourages Apgar to keep looking for those quiet moments that tell the story of the fisherman beyond the boat. Who are these people? How do they live their lives? What are their struggles and their joys? Is there a bigger picture to be told? I would encourage Apgar and this newspaper to push to tell stories that go a little further (beyond the action shots of hauling and gutting fish), to tell the stories through expressions and relationships between these people. Nice work. Keep it up.”

Finalists

Fort Collins Coloradoan
Sam Wilson, reporter

For intern Sam Wilson’s photography, multimedia slideshow and article called “Fading Legacy, Bright Future” in the Fort Collins Coloradoan about the town’s thriving Holiday Twin drive-in movie theater.

Judges said: “Sam Wilson did a nice job reporting this feature story about Fort Collins’ Holiday Twin drive-in theater. It’s exciting and heartening to see an intern working to tell each aspect of the story- through photography, slideshow and a print story- a balance that is not easy to achieve. This judge especially enjoyed the back of the car portraits of all the different theater goers seen in the video. It’s a nice, playful touch. Keep looking for the humor and fun in these stories.”

The Marion Star
James Miller, photographer

For photographer James Miller’s images from a night on patrol for a story on how budget cutbacks affect local safety forces in Marion for The Marion Star.

Judges said: “Miller did a good job of visually covering a story that deeply impacts his community. It’s revealing to see what officers really have to deal with over the course of a single shift. Images like these help educate and inform readers- a service which is a cornerstone of community journalism.